                      ˿µϣ20050825գ

05.08.25, ӡʲͳԴս
05.08.25, Ԫɽ˿֮󡪡Բ԰ķиС
05.08.25, 硶Ҫ˽ġһѧ
05.08.25, ꡶ҿѧ㽭ѧζԴѧӵġһĵ顷
05.08.25, xjǸҪãҪԲݵ
05.08.25, ϡռǼҡ
05.08.25, ¡ʿѧBruce Hallٰ¡
05.08.25, ScienceλڸʲôNSFC򱨵
05.08.25, һʦһҫ
05.08.25, ʡУУϢƽ̨ʧܵһ֤ط
05.08.25, yanchenҲ˵СĸԺǶǿˣ
05.08.25, Ӻơڡ͢һ284¯Ȼδ𣿡ȶ
05.08.25, beiheEnlightenҹڤ롢bingoһԱļѧ

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

                     ʲͳԴս

                            ӡ

    һеĹ۵Ϊڽѧ֮䲢ڲɵ͵ìܣ
ڽѧ໥ͻĴͳ˹ʱıǩЩʱʿȻ
Եڽ̽籣ѧṫѧУĿѧ̨ļսӶ
ⳡսĺǣѧУ˽֮̽⣬ǷӦͬʱ
ԵһۡۡΪ
ڸӣǽģֻĳָ߼Ƴģ

һʲͳĴģɱ

    81գʲͳڵݽ5ҵرֽĲɷã̸´£
Ҳ˳ʲͳԳǡġɻͽҲ
ԭּͽϵǲԶġ
ҲԸŭ۵֧ߣԥԥ˸ǵشǰ
ݳʱ˵أӦɵط
ҾúߵĹ۵㶼Ӧúúõؽ̡̽ǲ
ô¡ΪһǽӴͬ˼ɣ
ҿɲšǷӦýӴͬĹ۵㣬ҵĻش
ǡǡ

    ûעⲼʲͳ90ӵķ̸лʲôֻ⺬
ļ仰һĴģɱѧ壬
ѧЭᡢˡѧѧ
ѧᣬʲͳ۵ʲͳζֵȻ
Źᣬϯ϶ڽܵӲɷʱָزʲѧ
ûʵݡʲĿѧʿڵڶ
벼ʲ˽ޣִѧĻʯ
ǿѧ

۵Ľ

    ҪΪʲôʲͳϿƫеļ仰ô
粨ҪŽʷ졣

    1859ķԴ֮ڶ̶̵ʮ䣬۾
Դȷ֤ѧ磬ΪΪοĿѧ֮һ
ԺҲûиıǴӽ۵֮ŷ۵Ļ
̱ĿҲͿʼˡ20֮ԭּ
Ϊȫ練ĴӪ
۷糱1925ﵽ˶壬15ֹڹѧУ̽۵
3ݻͨݴѧνʦ˹˹
Ϊ̽۶硣ΡСΪ
һΪǴӺӽġ
ʵġС

    ˹˹1970ȥʱڷȡʤ1967꣬
᳷˷۷1968꣬˹Сʯǵһλ
ʦսݵķ۷˾һֱ߷Ժ߷
Ժ̷Ϊо۷Υܡ

    ԭּͽӴ˸ı˲ԣϿѧ£Ϊ
ѧۡٹֹۣ̽ҪѡѧۡΪѧ
ͬȶԴ1987꣬·˹ͨɣҪڹѧ
УѧۡͬȽʱ䡣·˹ݵĿѧʦսһ
ɣ˾ͬ߷Ժ߷Ժ϶ѧۡ
̣ڹѧУΪѧ۴ڣͬʱ䷨ҲΥܡ

    ԭּͽٴθıԣ۸ĳɡۡΪ˱
⴫֮ӣСرֱᵽϵۡʵس֮Ϊ
ܡôĿѧԼڱϿһֿ
ѧۡԼҲ֪СϷƭ˿ѧʿ
רҵʶͨĶʩѹԼ
֮һΪԭּͽԼһ˲ۣܽˣ
ۡ䲻ûгرڱصϷв
ⳡݸ˶úңҲΪɹ

    1999꣬ۡ˶ڿ˹ݳսݣݽίԱ
64۵ݴݽɾвСһʱΪ
ȫȵ㡣ȫýĳЦУ˹ݵѡýίԱе
سԱ¿ΣµѡĽίԱָ˽еĽݡ
ǵ2004꣬һֵѡ֮󣬱سԱ810ձ
´жԽشĿǰȫ20׼
ս۽ѧһЩطĽȲ޶
ѧαǰ۵ڽѧ֮ǰУѧ
ʵһۣҪضԴơ
ЩƲɱѾͽᱻϷͥ

ۡαѧ

    һпѧۣҲҪ䡢֮ǡ
ۡûܶԽκεĲ䣬Եģǽ֮к
Ĳֻ֣Ĵҥķƭжѡ磬
ڡ֮ۡ£˶˵ִ󱬷
еĶȺһҹ֮ںͣ5ڶǰһʱڣ
ͻȻ֣ƺǽġۡǣں
֮ǰĵʱڣڶදֳ֣͵Ķﲢ
гֵģִ󱬷һ͵ģǳ
ꣻ͵ĶֻԭʼͣԺֶ𽥽ġ
ˣִ󱬷һ㶼ͻı
֡

    ۡһǣĽṹӶ޷
𽥽Ǿ˵۾Ϊ˵۾
ĸֶȱãôɲ۾𲽽
ʲôãʵڡԴѾشˣ
۾ȻãżʣѲͬ۾Ӽ
ӡӲʹƲ۵Ľ̡
ңӦǷǳģƳ
˵۾ʵôǴࡰơȱݣǷǳ
޴ġơֻڽǵŲ

    ۡʲôۣһٶǰͱѧ
ľɽҸȼκѧֵڿѧ
ȨѧѧԺѧٽᣨ
ĿЭһۡαѧֻн۲ǿѧ
ۣǿѧʵ

    ҲͲⲼʲͳòƹĻƽ̽ǿ
ҵķӦۡһֲͬĿѧ۵ĻôȻ
ҲѧѧϰѧϰǡۡαѧڿѧĽ
ûλõġѧĽòǻȻгھ˻Ȼ
֮ŴڵĳĻǲҲӦڿѧѧ
ռ˵һмǧԱĵƽѧᣬݡʥ
϶ƽģԲģǲҲӦѧѧϰ
ͬġѧ۵㡱

    ѧʦϻִл᳤άԲʲָ
ȥһźţΪѧ쵼Ȩȴ
һαѧɢ˾йһܸˡά
˽й״Ļԭּ
Ĵͬһɷ۵İйӿ˼й
ѧӰ첻ɵ͹ĵĺϻӡ֮ġۡ
¿ѧɹй۵ıҲʱˣ
ⳡѧڽ̵ĳͻйýϳɽ
ܵԿѧɡ

    ˣǽעġԴսӦñͼ
ֻĿ̬ǹעΪ˶ûйķѧ
ָ߶Ⱦ裬δѣйһĻ

2005.08.21

й걨2005.8.24.

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

ɽ˿֮󡪡Բ԰ķи

Ԫ

    ˼ȡСһλ

    Բѧ˵ʲôǿѧҪ꺢˵ʲôһ
ݡѧά˵˿ͨһ䡣Ȼˣ
ôܿ϶˵ҩƬܴҩƿ˹̹˵һԼߵ
˶еʱͻȻˣʱΪʲôͲܻ˼䣿
ǣάɡ˹̹˵һ˵λɽ˽ǣ
ĵƣݻؼңƤȻָƿڴ
ģΪʲôȻ˵ƣҲɽ˿
ǣ˼ҲˣҲˣǸн֮ҵĽ
ģѧڹ˵ȷʵ˹µȻˣѧȻ
ԵĲʵֵĶ绽꣬ҩƬƿӣ
ͲôʵСѧƭ

    նά裬ʱʵ֡ˣҲᱻ㻨
һλʵֵˣһҵƾߵ꣬ٻͻȻӵһ
֪ͨһλȨƵɽҪ˱ꡣôλƾߵϰָ
ӦԣԽһģԹҳսƣ̵㣬ͣҵһ졣ǲ
һ㲻ɵӹ꿴ַͬҵ׷׷ЧһʱнһƬ
ȫŴˡɽ˼״Ȼŭ𣬶򵨱һȨ֣
Уų˭ͣҵҵ⡣ǲҲ㲻ܵ
иͷģиҲоʮϵ꣬Ըӭӹ͡
ɨͥʽƾ߶һֻݣ
Ƥ۵ĵطɽĴ˽꣬ϲ⣬˩Ƥ
¶Լ뵽ˣ佱һƤŵĵ
ˡ

    ˵ƾߵԲ԰棬ôƤŵĵݡ
ۣ

    һǡԲ԰׷ûлӰۣӻ
Ƕȷԭ̷ȱݡڹƺͽУȱȫ
Ч̬ʩˮ̬ϵͳƻĿǰ̴󲿷Ѿ
ɣӰ˻״ĵͷӰ˼ѡ
̶̬ӰͶԺ̸ʧڹûаʵ
ʩӰɵġ

    ڶǡĿǰûʹøĤϲԵı
ϻѺԵȻϡǵԲ԰ǹصﱣλַ
԰ԣӦȲ˵ķϺʹʩ

    ѧ֮֮Ϊڽ۵ĵݱͨ߼ĵ֤
ĵԴȴȱ߼֤ݵ֧֣Ƥŵĵݡ
Ҳδز֪ЩŹ֣ر
޶ʱڣԻӰ۹еĲ죬и߶ȵԡԡ
ԣڻӰ۵ĹȺԶԽͬȹģĽ
Ŀ֮ʷѧҿԡ֣Ҳ֪ǱѰ
뵽ȥһ鵱ʱıֽЩŹֽ۸⡣

    һۡνԭ̷ȱݡǡڹƺ
УȱȫЧ̬ʩˮ̬ϵͳƻ
ԭ̷ʩʱˮŹ⣬ˮûˣ̸Ρˮ̬ϵͳ˵
ƺҲ֡Ƿһ룬繤̡лӰۡ
ʲôԱ⡰ˮ̬ϵͳƻأʹѷĤĳճ
ҲҪŸˮʩƻȻɱ⡣ԡƻ
˵ЩֵֹˡһڽϱСåڶͱһ˿ڿ
5ףȴ͸Ĥ˵ܵ˺ǡġβ
ͬ˿ڣ˵ܵ˺Ĳˡ˵ˮֱ
ķҲУһž޴עѻ֬ע䵽һƬ
ɣֻɱ̫ߣʩѣЧҲ̫ãԺ˲áΪ˱
һһͿԻָġˮ̬ϵͳ˴󶯸ɸ꣬ʵڲֵá
βҲδطǵڶƤϿӣڵĴ󳦾¼쵽С
βȻ⣬ټһе֣β᳦ڲ
Ҳδذ첻ֻרҵŮ֮⣬ƺںС
ϵ˰̣Ҳû˷ѾȥоӸβ¼˶ָҽ
βԲɡ˺Ǻ޵ġ

    ڶ۾͸ûеˡȻĿǰûʹøĤϲ
ԵıôۺϻѺԵȻϡ˵к
ݣڻвûиۺϻѺԡЩԼۣ
۾ûκμ֤Ŀԡ˵ף˵Ҳҩʹ
ȻԭϣûиáһǿѧĽֻۣǡ뵱Ȼ
Щҩûиõ˴ԳԵơͶһҩĸá
ҽİ˷ǣ¡¡͡¡塢һǸá

    ʵĤҲԲáȻϡޡ顢˿
Ȼά֯ɲͿͩͻ֮ȻˮϣƳˡȻ
ĤЩȻϡɱߡ̣ҽ︴
ӣѺԡùʽͲɡ˶Ӧ̹ζ
ԵɡɡԺܿͱ̭ˡ͸˵ˣˢͿ
ʩ߼ʹŷϻǱҧһƬƬ񣬴˶Դ
䶾Կ֪

    ڻճ䡰ۺϻѺԡǵڸ
ĤճĿɾͻƻֲũҲǽֹճשҪ
ɡеͳŷҲǶԻƻ븴
Ĥ޶޺ȣճпжкģݱ걨2005.8.21A2
桶ж4000Ц¶ݡһıϵжġס
ճҪǣĤճķЧҪöࡣ

    ݻṩ֣Բ԰ȫĤˮ
©Ϊ48.5 m3ָĤճ棬ˮ©
133.7 m3ճȫĤÿˮ85.2m3
ˮĿǰˮÿ1.31Ԫ㣬Ҫึˮ110Ԫϡôÿ
໨һٶԪˮѻʲôǷԲ԰̬أǡǡ෴
©ˮֻ̬лûкô

    һˮģԤԲ԰̶
DOBOD5 Ӱ첢TNTP ӰΪʵʩ
ܱ֤ʵˮ彻TNTP ŨȻߣӶӴˮ帻Ӫ
ķաΪάˮˮʣṩʵˮ彻ǱġĿ
һΣЩ˿ܻõĤˮʶ񻯷յӡȻ
ٿΣͻᷢˣ

    Ϊֹˮˮʶ񻯣ʵʩԱṩһĽˮ
ԭƲˮˮάˮˮʡԭ龰IIǸĽ
龰IIIҪ겹ˮӦС400 m3

    Բ԰Ѿӽɣʩˮ޷ˮ
ԭ״廪ѧ2004 ļݣԲ԰ˮˮʲܴ
رˮ׼GB38382002III ׼͡ˮˮ
ʱ׼GB 12941 91 B ׼ˮʸӪ״̬

    ӶԿǲ÷Ĥ龰IIǲճ龰III
ͬҪ400m3Ĳˮδ2004꣬ˮҲһĵ׳ꡣ
Ҳ˵ˮʶķ޹ء

    ˮﲻ400m3ڱȱˮֻܲ200m3
£ôߵͺˡȫɿݣ
ˮ̬ϵͳƻճġĽȫĤ
ԭȣ©϶ʣˮȽ٣Ⱦͬ£
ȾŨȻȽϸߣˮʻӶ񻯡ɴ˿ɼġĽ
ʵǸĶ񷽰

    ߶ԴӦ÷ǳԾаѡĽΪ
һ֡龰꾡ķյĵ15¡뽨顷
15.2顷УԴˡĽȴֻδᡣ˵
Ϊһֿ˲ճķȴûʽһ

    С˵úܶԣ˵ƣҲɽ˿ɽһ
עƫҪƤŵĵݵġһЩȱݵ˵
ǳ˿֪Ƥ磬ԴЩ޸ݵĻڶе
ǻ֮֮ҹ֮˶ѡһ
ܱצëܱһ鶼ŲϺŵķ
ܱɡġǸʫˣʫġʫУʵ
ò̫ͬӽѩ˵ɽߡҲ˵
ؿʵдڵĶֻǻеĶ

    뿴˵
    
http://www.zhb.gov.cn/eic/649094490434306048/20050707/9434.shtml

    Ĥ谭Ȼزеˮ̡ˮ£
ڷĤϲĵгӪʺηֵĻۣӴˮʶ񻯵ķ
աҲǸƤŵĵݣ̷ĤĿľΪ˷ֹˮ
ڷĤϲĵгӪʺηֵĻۡ޻̸֮ڵ
ˮ֮䣬κһĿŨȸһʱʶһɢ
ﵽƽ⣬֮ܳ֡ۡЧϲ
ճӴ˸ɿݵķգˮ̬ԣûˮķҪˮʶ񻯵ķ
صöࡣ

    ˵ܷĤĿǰδ֤жԣȻȻ
Ĥ̬ҪںߴĤȻܹγɲάֽ
ˮ򾰹ۣڶʹˮԻָ谭ˮ彻Ͳ
Ժ׺ͺߵֲӰ졣ͬʱڹ̽
ȱЧıʩˮ̬ϵͳƻˣù̴
ĤǲѧģҲǲӦᳫģȫġſ
ӡνȻĤ̬Ҫ֮˵
Ȼȫġ

    ķĻԣˮġԲ԰ļ㿴
һкȫ˴׸ȤǣʾԲ
԰ַ԰¼лĲɣʷش̬ġֵ
ֽܾͣԲ԰̺ܵĸ߶ȹעù̴ӽ֤ͣ
ֱߵọֶܾ̈̄ṫϣܽƽ
Ľ̡ṩһҪƽ̨ʹڵĸܵ
Թ㷺Ľͨһ͸ʽʹִΪʱ
ܹ۵ļලǿѧߡߡߵִˮ
ƽҵ˵ҵȫҵҪȫĹͬж
Բ԰ʼյĻ룬˵ɳչģ
ȫȻɵʶˮƽٽȻˡ
ĺггҪļֵ

    λȥһ׻ֵͲֻձˣ
Լһᷴѧڽ̵Եġ͸
ȴҲǶԼȫͬġǿǶڱд
Լʾ𡣾ݱķ֮ǰҲټר
ûбЩרҵеİʮѰζЩר
֪ķ֮߾Ȼרзרǵ
ԸԳеΡΣķҪԶʷ
Уᡰ͸ˡ

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

Ҫ˽ġһѧ

ߣ

ġҿѧ㽭ѧζԴѧӵġ һʱ
֪Լ𾪣ŭǱйѧĹٱλѾѱӦ
ĹػŤһɶĴ󽴸ף

С˺УŹ˽
˷ָ

һλ˽ڻعƵĸУʼνЧʺʦ
ʱһʱֱڿ죬Իõ90%£ʦʿɷ
ЧʿɼӱĬȻйĴѧ췽ҹ̸Աǹ٣
ʦѧֻ񳼷ڹ٣ʩйٷģٿ
ѧ۹˽ѧѧУˣԱΪ֮
ѧϵϵϵһټϵﲻĸ飬ǳ
ճ񣬻ڴʼӡļGRANTѧ
ʱİæӦԱйѧ洦İۣ
Įֱ𲻵

MARYLANDϵһλʦ---ְλһͷй
ϰ߸óΪ쵼 ΪҲԸѺб
---һΪдĹоѯУҶʱӦ
УԱһͬĻḻͿеľ顣оٳʮ
ǰéļԺϵѧǡؽţ
ʵMarylandˣУ󶼹ѧʱ߳ȥųҪ
һѧй춽꣬ʹϿֶδ
һѧߵѧְҵҲ֪ĽڣԱѧ
£𾪣һЩһ ںſԺɤӵ
ѧ쵼ǣʲôһǿ˵ġһġһ 
˽ġһйѧΪҲһָܣְ
Ȩĸܣǲ۲۵ĸܣ

йѧͳһƬ˽ķΧ
ʼѧʱƴεΪ٣˴ٵìͷƴĳ
ʱƴ̬180ȴתģɼǰʱֲ֧Ϊ²
ֻϲϴͬǵĶУ¶ʱһ
Ƭ֧֮ȵԼ캭类¶ʱֱһá
ȻЩѧУҲִ֧٣һиܵȺǵһ
˽Ĵ󻷾Ե˵΢־֮ܵĶӣйѧ
ﷺĵ֪ʼʱǸòȻ٩٩̸
ģٶ۾ݵĲ԰ѡʶϤĵܣ˹Ⱥ
ԵĲԺʿˮԥȫת޸ѧӲ֪߳ܺΣ
ٿΪԶ绤ϴΪ캭Ҷƽ ѧЩ
ϰڶ쵼ͱĿȾԴ̵ѧ޴
Ǿ֪ʵվսʤԣǾ׽Ʊֻἤıӣ
ǼûҲûǻȥʵΪһŤε磡
--- ߻Ȥдһйѧıμǡ

йǱսʤԹ򣬺߲ʵͷƩ
иʵ»ҳƶϵһɣXYZҳһɡ
걻ѧ侮ʯĽƸһλѧĽʦȴְȻ
йƶȵִдϵ˶졣ʵĹٱλУֺαؽʲ
ôƶȣͽȻ˷ѵΪȨһЩȥĲPGֽˡ
ЩXXѧߵĺͬγûаֹֽ涨FULL-TIMEĹ
Ĵѧ͸˶ղʽĵλ۱֮ۡϰ
˰ԩͷȨմʵоѧʵģһȥգ

йѧĸᣬֱӰ쵽˵˼
ĸܡһ߼뷨йѧгɹķǸܵĽ
йѧҪѧһһ㷨ңңڡ
Ҫܡ һٷİʲộʲô
ֻҪѸִһǰȥˣ

"Ŀǰ׼ʽ磬տгϯб㷹
͡éҲе·ҲвиҰҲжݳгտ۲
ʵˣҲжôÿĵĺӣִۡʮһڣν
йߣʵǰŸõ硣νйߣʵ
ǰĳ֪ǿˡģ򣬴˱Զ
䣡"

йѧĽ³ѸʵλȻ
ܵǹסǧԪıµҽƣ޲ǰӵ
Ӧ֣֪꣬ʵ»ǧǧĬĬŵͨ˵
ĵǷʽȴ֪һȺ鵽ľٵͬ
۵ɥʧ˸ѧʲôɾͣ

йѧܺã---  

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

꡶ҿѧ㽭ѧζԴѧӵġһĵ

ߣ

˺زʶΪˣоһҪ
˵㽭ѧһֱΪѧ⽻ѧϰᡣ٣
ʵҵʦãȥ۽ȥˣÿ궼Уȥڷ
Ҳ㽭ѧı¹Ӧ˵㽭ѧ򿪷š

1.㽭ѧĹ涨ҪԪҵĳѺ𣨲㽭ѧ
򣬾оԺʦѾȡѺ𣬵оԺҳ
ûпӦļ

ǵģǰܶѧУߣ200210»11
֮ȡˣѧ20029·ݳμӻʱ2Ѻ
𣨵ʦǩֵ⽻20035·ѧȥѧϰ
ͷǳ򵥣Ѻˣ2004ٶȳȥһýѺ
һ㣬n㽭ѧѧõ֤ʵļԲ㽭оԺ
http://grs.zju.edu.cn/main8.htm

2㽭ѧѧĹ̡

̣ѧ飬㽭ѧ޹ϵΪǶģ
²Ǳίĵλԭλͨ
㽭ѧֻҪԭλͬ͸ѧӶѧʺ
֮У

3.ָ㽭ѧоԺ˵ʼ˵ڵ, 
ʾ޷õѧ´ûеõظ
ձʿ⣬ͬʱͨʼѧѧ⡣

Ҫʼص£Ϊʲô绰
㽭ѧоأʼ͵ĬˣΪʲôǿ
õʼͨأѵԼûΣ

4. 20049³, һƪѾ,һƪ,
Ȼѧ,׫дʿġ

20049µʱѾ꣬һѧڶ
ûѧ㽭ѧоѧ涨ʵʩϸ޹ʲעᣬ
ֹѧ㽭ѧδ֮УѧôҪ飬㷢ʼ˵һ£㽭
ѧоԱͰѧͣˣҪãΥ
ѧѧ涨ȣԼѵûд

5. ˾˽⣬֪ѧֹһλʦ
㽭ѧʿλʦ˽ѧ´ȥȻˣ
ѧҪ㽭ѧȡλʦĲʿѧ˲пṫ
ܽȨʵ˷ָ

λ˿ЦãѧΪʲôֹͬ㿼λʦ
Ȼ˽̹£ǲӷﰡУ㹤ˣҪܽ
Ӧôְѧû˵˷˼Դأռſӣùʣ
ϿΣʿʲô¶㣬ѧʦôɣ˼ѧҪ
Ҫ찡

6Ϊ㽭ѧǧ಩ʿͶƱѡĴ㽭ѧʿ
ḱϯ

ǸЦˣʿҵҲûȥͶƱ

ѧʦѧĹϵǧ˿ƣΪ˷ְ飬
֪ϵһζǿ㽭ѧ˺ܶ鷳
㲻ӦöʲôʿоӦôְȥձʿ
˾ĺѧˡ㽭ѧĵʦ˲ѧ
ô˾ţ֮ĲʿأûȥձĻᣬ
һòѧλ㲻ǿˡ

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

ǸҪãҪԲݵ

ߣxj

¼Ĺؼ⣬ڰսǰûа;ȽѺ
Ϊɳһ涨Ȼ涨ܴĲӦ÷ϳ
ԳƵձȥʿģ۱չɻ˽ӦýǮ
ʵϣ˽ǮҪ١˽ְ
ίͬѲʿѧϰίתԷѡעίϹǲǮģ
ѧ㽭ѧǮһͼ򡣰ѷͲѧѼֹ

⣬㽭ѧʿѧְĴͱ
𣬿϶йʣתԷѵĻѧУЩ˶Ҫġ

෴ͨϵ߽ݾʿѧһӶﵽѸ޵Ŀġ
ʱΪĺ

ûнѺ뿪ְѧϰѧ´Ȼܰ
ﵱְԴڿ

ѧһûͬ⣨ҽѧԺ쵼˽˰æѧУ
ʽͬ⣩ȻҲԱԼְ

ίǸ¡ѧû
ͬ⣬ҲûܹѧͬȻ
ֹͣѧ

ѧУѧй涨ġѧ밴ʱѧѧ벹ܶ
ѧԭûвȻֹͣѧ

⣬һ꣬Ƿǳ͵ķŰ׸Ȼﱾ
˿ܲ롣ΪѧУί൥λȫְλ
תԷѲʿԷѲʿȻԸȡ

ȻΪԼ˲ţԼĸУЧعΪ
ȴһչΪѧУƾ˱֤¡

׷ԴѺԷѷΪѧѧһȥص
Һ͵λǮ㣬ȴҪƻͬ޵Դ˷ѣ
㲻Ӧýʵ϶ԳԱѺǶѧĹƽϾ
ĲʿǹҺѧǮġڳȥع̫ˣһͷ
汣֤Լ

ѧĴȱһĵĹ涨ԭ¡
¼ϾѧУѺУûкͬѧУڲίȡ
ԡ顱ΪԡʵΪ

Ϊ˽߽ݾһͬʱ
ѧλֲ벹Ѻ𣬰¡ûΪ
ͬѧӰ죬뵽ʿӰ졣ܶѧ
¾ʹʧȥӦоᡣ

ѧԸĽʦӡǷǳЦ˵
ܲʾԸܡпԿ뷨ԼҲҪܡ

ÿζԹĸı䶼ڲع߿ӵȷѵġϧ
Щ˵Ŀȴ˽Ǳ˸ԼҲ븯ܵ

һ˼Ѻ𷣿򣬵ʱ˹ʣ
Ԫһ£ΪУѧ롣ҷԽѺ𷣿ȣں
ѧԱĵʣľԼֻǱ֤˵Ĺƽ

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

ռǼ


20050824й걨

ϸ£֣NASAײ̹̽ն1ǣ
ȫĿ⡣һ˹ռʿžǸĺûᣬڶ˹
ԺNASAҲֱΪѹ棬³XŮʿΪ
ײ̽ײռԤ⣬칬ͼΣʹ
ܵ˺ΪˣNASA87¬൱ײĿԤ㡣

 ýı˹ķԺδĿͥڡ׮˾
ΣXŮʿƺѾﵽĿġҿ״NASA
ΪԼռһƭ

 NASAΪֹδʽӦXŮʿߡNASAʦһ
򵥵ػӦⳡƵĹ˾XŮʿ״ûκεΪ뼸С
ȣײǵֻ̽мٹأײǹĸı΢
΢ײ֮ǵĹתڣ5ֻࣩ˲1룬ֱ
ײһܲ767ɻ

 ţһλѾ㹻򷢵XŮʿˡȻΣXŮʿ˳
ռԣҪᷴĿռ
ֹϵαѧƭ

ȥXŮʿΪռӦðǵӰҲǽȥȻXŮʿ
֪̹ն1ʵ1867űѧҷֵġ֮ǰռ
ܰǽȥȤǣ1881꣬ľӰ죬̹
1ǵĹˡ֮ռǷǵϷԵı仯
ԼɵĺأƺûСΪָܿܿԽռǴʦǣ
һصĴ

 ðɣʦǽ̹ն1ǷǵռУӽռ
ûˡ𣿴ʦƺûпǹǡ
ǡǼʷϺܶĴǡ÷ˣά9ǣǰ
ײľǡռǹ

 ҲʦǷѾ˼дԼռЩһϯ֮ء
ѧһôʦǾϢ̫ϵУǵʤ
̫ϵ߽İ¶ƴǵëռѵӦðǶ
ȥ

ǣ̫ϵлƵСǣǶŽռ̿
顪ôһֽ̿ĻƺԵЩƽˣ
һѧƷ̫ϵʮǡǣҲһѧ
ΪֻӦñ壨˳˵ѧΪ
Ҳʮ־ˣڤǵĴǵλҲӦȡռӦô죿
ѧϻῪʮǻ̫ϵΪ˴ǣô
ǿѧҵһͶƱ͸ıռ˵ǣ·ֵ
ڤǻ󡣺Ȼ729֮ǰռûпǵڤǸ
Ҫļһ

 ʵϣѧռʵ飬ʾռϹ
û

 ҪлXŮʿòЩѧףǾܹᵽռ
ɵ㡢©ì֮κһԾ߻ɾˣʶЩ
ì֮󣬶Ӧõóһۣռһƭ

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

ʿѧBruce Hallٰ



Ϊ˿ĳѾжˡƽĶۣҼÿ˿
ǷЩʮּĴ¡Ϊд
λдտսӰӵĿ¸ʤ
֮⣬Ҫ֮оݣŷ¶ֻЩ
ʹ˶£ɷ羰

˵ӽٳʵ˶⣬Ը˵Ӵ
ʵòʧǴٵڸڿºѧϵĳɾ͡
ȴֲòӺ˿Ȼ˿¶¼
ģû˿ѧĳŵˣ¼ȴֻ»
ࡣ

ͨΪйкܶ鲻⣬ʱҲķ̽Ϊʲô
Щ𣬵ڹ˲ʵҲ١ ҵΪ
˿վзӣҲΪڶļʶ㣬ִԣ
ȿݵ˿ѶԺǽ¶׶ˣָܣ۹ɶ
ûǵĺӣ𣬶۽󿪣ǳ

ȥĸʵ»¼ʱʱдƪģɷŵ
ϡʵϱ˴ǰûд£ǴβΪ˱ʾԸʵ»Էѧ
ĸΪ֧֣Լر˿վһһƥ֮𡣵
ʱᵽʿѧ UNSW Bruce HallٰĴʵֻ
˵˸¼ʵһ档֮ԲԸܲʵһǲΪĳЩ
ṩһڣ˵Ȼ¹ⶼΪʲôҪ棿ͬǲ
Եƫ˵һ󳭡

ѧһDaiwenվ  http://www.daiwen.com
רѧģλһѼרд֣Գн飬д
ʮƪUNSW£һƪд05726գ֮ܶ˵UNSW
øǰУRory Humeֱö˱һʱȫ۵µĻ
дһƪ½˽Rory HumeˣDaiwenվ
ǣDaiwenվ 726ûٸ¹뵽Ӱö
˿ĻΪһ߶˿ĻرԵõ˿
ǵָ̣Ǽʮȫһûпڶͬʵظ
Ҫʹֽ 

UNSWBruce Hall£

20019UNSWӵҽѧԺBruce Hall4ľٱָHall
ѱʵ飬רȨףԵΪȡUNSWָҽѧԺԺBruce 
Dowtonֵ顣
2002413հABC̨Dr Norman Swan¶¼
2002417УJohn Niland˼ȫָءCouncilҪ
֯Ķ顣
20026BrennanС飬20031ɱ棬öHall
scientific misconduct
200312УRory HumeBrennan棬öHallΪֻ
academic misconductֻǹ֡
20044Rory HumeȴְУMark WainwrightУְ
Councilͨ飬ȷBrennan棬natural justiceͬһָزӦ
ڶεԼHALLùڰΪɾBruce Hallߡ

ҪBruce HallԹʲôӰ죬ҵ

1   ѧҲһƬԶЩڹȹڹڴ
ѧһ󲻱벻ͨ

2   UNSWBruce HallǰWilliam McBrideĿƼٰ
ص15HallظMcBride֤еʵ
ֻͽ˵ΪHall޸оѧ
ܵԴͶԲߣUNSWӲɲ

3   20031112Rory Humeйڣ޷ǽѧ
һѧ֮࣬ڵĽӴλӦöHumeΪ˽⡣

4  Rory HumeڼݴѧְһдѧȥݴѧRory 
HumeȥֽνһѧֻҪֳЦɲ

һλ뱾ϽڣϤѧMBA̹һйĹԱ
һϿBruce HallΪ̲ģһǣУδHall
˻شǱҲ˵¹ϵѧУš
󲻽⣬û뵽йĹԱ̹ʣǵŸ߱ˡ˵
ǣJohn NilandRory HumeMark Wainwrightʵϴ˰޴ѧ
߲ΡȻѧ˵İ˵ľϣ¶
δеͨһԸߡеֻ᲻
һ˵ƾͱζԺһҲûﵽ¯ľ硣й
УУ棬UNSWЩҪǺ˵˽

ǰ˿Czf ԹĹѯ˾ҲҪ١һģ
ͬߵĹ۵㡣St James Ethics CentreרҵĹѯ˾Rory 
Humeϸ֮ǰҲѯ⡣Ȼܾʹȫ񶨹ѯ˾
Ե飬Թѯ˾ĽڸԼʧְʵһ
С

ͶDaiwen׾ĸ¼£ΪǻӦѼRory Hume
õĶЩ̱䣬Ұ

˽UNSW ǰУRORY HUME

ȫ۵  16 August  2005

δѼڲѼ֪δȥֿ˹Rory 
HumeϢѼUNSWǰУ (Vice Chancellor) Rory Hume
£ƪ빣ͼĲïȴ֪һЩйRory 
Hume ĲܹʵĴţͷѼõϳĴ󣬵ʱдŸ֪
ѼTharukaǹƪ£޷ѵֵһϷ
Ѽι˸ţѱֻò߱ªڴ˶Rory HumeĹ¹
β֮ѼͶָ

ʱ

Rory Hume Ƿݴѧʮͷļһ̧
Hume ǷûݴѧԼĨڣԮBruce Hall ֪ĺͲ֪
ѧǰIan McKenzie Stephen Lynch David Sachs Alex Bishop
мīˮRob Loblayķȥ㲻ʷЦϣΪBruce Hall
Meg LeesԱ㲻޳ͣһʵ磬ֻ迴ָ
Bruce Hall ѧթƭ֤Ƿ

UNSWһHallļϣȻڹؼ֮ͿһƬڣ
м仹ǿԿBruce Hallѧթƭ֤Bruce Hall
ָBrennanAllegation 5̾ΪֹȴUNSW
Allegation 1 Allegation 4Ĵַ
(http://www.secretariat.unsw.edu.au/council/Hall_Matter_3/Hall_Index.h
tm)

Allegation 4 ǹBruce Hallڡѧ־ϵһƪ: The 
Journal of Immunology 1998, 161:5147-5156  ͱճ£

DA PVG LEWIS F344ֲͬϸȽһ±ͱ
ݣϸĵĶҲѾ˿֮ĵһ(PVG 
grafts 7 (3), 11 (2), 13, 15, 18, 19, 22, 27, 34; Lewis grafts 11(5), 
13 (2), 18 (2) 21, 27, 29)ȱĵһ(PVG 13, 15, 18, 19, 22, 27, 
34) ĵڶ(F344 13 (2), 18 (2), 21, 17, 29) ֻǰ
ݡĵ(PVG 27, 28, 31, 34, 36; Lewis 13, 25, 26, 31, 
36) ĵʮʮ(PVG 27, 28, 31, 34, 36) (F344 13, 25, 26, 
31, 36) ȫͬѧͳƵѶɺϼʹپ
ʷҲܷBruce Hall֧һֱڽֻѧҲ
ʸԣȻҿؿҪ֤ݸҪκѧ֪
ʶ

Bruce Hall ԷͥHall v The University of New South Wales [2003] 
NSWSC 511 revised - 13/06/2003̨ܾͥABC  TV 
Four Corners ͨMeg LeesԼԵʱUNSWĸУMark 
WainwrightһҧȷʵͬʵеõĲ˼
ͬݡ

ǣBrennanAllegation 1ͬݻBruce Hall Ͷ
ѧ־һƪδУTable III, the data line 1 
is (PVG grafts13, 15, 18, 19 22, 27, 34; Lewis grafts 13 (2), 18 (2) 21, 
27, 29) and the  data line 3 is (PVG grafts 27, 28, 31, 34, 36; Lewis 
grafts 13, 25, 26, 31, 36)Bruce HallĽƱ硰ͬʵе
ͬݡܽΪʲôͬʵϱΡ
Ҫǣ Bruce Hall Brennan  Ϲͬݶ
ͬһʵ飬 һBrennanʾдѧ־Ҫ
ż Brennan  33ҳ 

Bruce Hall òBrennanͬݶ
ͬһʵ顣ΪNHMRCThe National Health and Medical Research 
Council Ĺ涨·֮ʵԭʼ¼뱣꣬
Hall޷ʾԭʼ¼ ֻ̹סHallMark WainwrightĿ
ȷʵͬʵеõĲ˼ͬݣһҪ
֤ʵظHallΪΪBruce HallMark 
WainwrightRory HumeѾĬЭ飬ֻҪBruce Hallܱڣ
Mark WainwrightRory HumeյȫաMark WainwrightHall
BrennanС̹׵ʵHallһ˫ɳ硣

뿴WainwrightAnnexure KBruce HallMark Wainwrightһ
Ͷ߿ġԭʼ¼ſڿӣƫѰס
Mark WainwrightɷнµдҪHallʵҽԺSouth Western 
Sydney Area Health Service(SWSAHS)ṩHallġԭʼ¼ʱHall 
Brennan ̹ЩʵStanfordģɸΪ֮Ȼ
SWSAHSǱҲòHallĸڡԭʼ¼Mark Wainwright
гΪSWSAHSṩHallġԭʼ¼оӦ
öBruce Hall

Wainwright֧Hall޻̸֮ͬHallȷͬʵõ
ȫһݣRory Hume ȴʶô˵BrennanAllegation 
1 Allegation 4 Hallظ˶ݡȻĻѼ
Bruce Hallȴӹһ١HumeWainwrightָҲ
編ƣBruce Hallоգһδξδ

֤ݣBruce Hall˵ֻǳ˲ôݣ
û취ƫƫHallո˵һҧû⵽֤
֤ݰֽֿڿѧ־ϣȻRory HumeٰӲ˵Bruce Hall
Ϊscientific misconductȻHarvard Medical School professor of 
surgery (immunology) David SachsԼƤBruce HallթƭϾ
ֽǧ˵ʷйĽۡ

ǰΪѧһʲţ˸ѧˡȴԸʰѼ
ۣѧթƭ߾ڣBruce HallMark WainwrightRory Hume
ֽթƭҸ˵Rory Hume ʵ֮ûԩ

Rory HumeֲУ棬Ȼҥ˵Hallָعİٶ
Brennanֻ϶мָض޻̸֮ʵһ Brennan
ףܹо24ָأΪHall֤Ѿ㹻
֣Բָûһ׷顣ѼåᣬΪHumeƽ
ʵϵʱCouncilԱǷǷִԣBrennan顣
ˣåȴHumeУˡ浣Humeܲ˷Ѽ
κһ

Ian McKenzie Stephen Lynch David SachsAlex bishopRob 
Loblay ˴ΪBruce Hall ԩһ˵Ȼ˵ó
һָΪʲôܳϵ¸صרұȱȽǣMark 
WainwrightRory HumeȴƫҪȥ⼸һǰԵ
עޣȢ

David Sachs Rob LoblayĵϸҲIan McKenzie
׹McKenzieºڣ˵֮ӽϡ 
ϧ쵽ˣΰԤӰӶûһ

Stephen lynchӽĿABC Four CornersͷTSANZ 
 Transplantation Society of Australia and New Zealandϯͷζ
ֹȻHall˽ԾӣشHallڰްһϰһ
LynchˣΪHall˵abcdeʵ鲻ʵûйϵȫ
ָصʵʡԭʼָHallûʵ鵫ƭ˵ˡLynch
ǸڣMark WainwrightȴȵؿڿάΪڡΪյ
ǣ Tony dApice ѧڣΪ˼HallĹ
WainwrightΪڣӴUNSWԵ 

Alex BishopΪηʥʵֻBruce Hall Сͽܣ
Bruce Hall ȥStanfordΪҹ֧HalḻWainwright
Rory HumeΪѧߡ뿴Լ
Dr Alex Bishop is research director of the Collaborative 
Transplant Group at the Centenary Institute, Royal Prince Alfred 
Hospital and Sydney University. He graduated from the Faculty of 
Agriculture at Sydney University in 1972 but moved to the field of 
transplantation research in 1982. He completed his PhD in 1990 at 
Sydney University supervised by Professor Bruce Hall and studied 
overseas at Stanford University and DNAX Research Institute, returning 
to the A.W. Morrow Liver Laboratory at Centenary Institute and Royal 
Prince Alfred Hospital, headed by Professor Geoffrey McCaughan. His 
primary interest is in transplantation immunobiology with a focus on 
the development of natural means to prevent rejection of transplanted 
organs and minimise the requirement of transplant patients for 
treatment with powerful but dangerous drugs to control rejection.

ۣȺ֡˭ϰԼˣMark 
WainwrightRory Hume˾ţﾡãЩһﾺ
óBruce HallԿǼΪ֣ȴع
ڶġȨУʯ쾪ʱ٣ѧ
羿мֳţ

Humeư

Rory Humeĵ̨Bruce Hall޹ϵ˵硣һΪBruce 
HallҲHumęԭȴǽڡһƪ˵ǳһλѧ֮
ֻСΧ£ΪUNSWλǰУΨRory Humeǰ
UNSWԨԴHumeκͷ¶ǰҪ뼰ʱ
չʾŻHumeڵκûгʣôܷ
Ѿǡ

ɥԾ죬Rory HumeȴȻ֪ڷһЩUniversity 
Ombudsman֮Ĳű߼ʵۡʼǶHumeĪŰɣΪ
ݴѧ϶й֮쳤վãд˵Humeڼݵ϶ʱֻ
ΩǴӣϴ̫ܸˡ

ǿʼHumeǷ쵼UNSWƫƫBruce HallһHume
ࡣҿӽĿABC Four Corners
http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/content/2003/transcripts/s960912.htm

STEPHEN MCDONELL: After an extensive seven-month inquiry examining 
the science, investigating documents and doing comprehensive interviews, 
the Brennan report was completed early this year. Bruce Hall received 
a copy and so did the university council. The council decided on 24 
February to distribute the report the next day. Copies would go to the 
complainants, government departments and bodies like the Ombudsman and 
the state's Independent Commission Against Corruption. But that night, 
Bruce Hall was informed of the imminent release. 

Did you tell Bruce Hall that it was going to be released? 

PROFESSOR RORY HUME: No. I've not...I've never contacted Bruce Hall. 
We've never spoken. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: Or his lawyers? 

PROFESSOR RORY HUME: Uh, his lawyers had asked us to be informed 
concerning the release and, yes, we honoured that request. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: Why did you do that? 

PROFESSOR RORY HUME: We honoured the request from...from his 
lawyers. It's the appropriate thing to do. The assessment of the 
university was that if we didn't honour that request the process could 
well have been compromised. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: Did you consider that this might allow him to 
obtain an injunction to prevent the report being released, which is 
what he went on to do? 

PROFESSOR RORY HUME: That was not part of my thinking then. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: Some university councillors were furious that 
the tip-off to Bruce Hall enabled him to get a Supreme Court 
injunction preventing the Brennan report from being released. 
Suspicion spread that Professor Hall would only have sought an 
injunction if the report was seriously detrimental to him. 

Why did you take out the injunction to stop the Brennan report 
being revealed? 

PROFESSOR BRUCE HALL: To protect the reputation of Sir Gerard 
Brennan. Because the alternative is that when the truth comes out 
about this report, it's fabrication and falsification and that's a 
very serious matter in science. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: You did it to protect the reputation of Gerard 
Brennan and not your own reputation? 

PROFESSOR BRUCE HALL: No. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: I mean, it looks like you're trying to hide that 
report. That you're trying to stop... 

PROFESSOR BRUCE HALL: Well, I think when a report is so wrong... 
You know, these are respectable people. I believe they tried to do an 
honest job and it was too tough for them because they didn't 
understand the science. And I was trying to protect their reputation, 
but at the end of the day, I'll protect mine, and they're wrong.

ǺϷ̨ǾУRory HumeͺպBruce Hallڸ
ڵ˼ҵˣһHumeBruce Hallò̹
Bruce HallʦBruce HallϷԺظBrennanԭΪ
BrennanߣӻǰЦϣһԻҲţHumeҸоͦ
ãǰHumeÿʦԱemail֪ͨǧҪ

һΪHumeHallǴͨõģHumeָBruce HallͨԺɱ
Brennan棬HumeҲȷûBrennanСͥ绤ҪȻHall
ʤ㡣ˣǳHallȴϵشܿ䣬û̵ˣ
о򱻷ɽƳΪHallòߵͷоɴ
أ
http://www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/scjudgments/2003nswsc.nsf/aef73009028d67
77ca25673900081e8d/14defd249e4a4bd3ca256d6d000c69a0?OpenDocument    
Rory HumeֻóಲԳBrennan棬 Ӷ
˾

ŵǣ˵Bruce HallѧԽժҪHall
ȴUNSW˵ǾٱڻϽժҪַݺǺû
Ū˭ѣҪץסٱߵİѱɱһ٣Bruce 
HallҲ˽᣿HumeʼûҲ飬ǴһRory Hume Bruce 
Hallһ˸񱰱ɣȻHumeܺ˼˰ٰӺ޳ܵBruce Hall
뿴 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: Professor Hall initially claimed it was Dr Chen 
who presented the abstract to the Transplantation Conference. Now he 
says April 2001 was a long time ago, and he can't remember who spoke. 

Do you accept now his version of events where he didn't present 
that...? 

PROFESSOR BRUCE HALL: I don't know who presented the abstract. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: Could it have been you?   

PROFESSOR BRUCE HALL: I don't believe so. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: But you don't know who got up and... I mean, it 
does seem remarkable that you wouldn't know who presented your 
abstract to a major conference. 

PROFESSOR BRUCE HALL: Well, it's not my abstract. It's his abstract. 

STEPHEN MCDONELL: Well, you wrote it. It really does seem 
remarkable that you can't remember who delivered that paper. 

PROFESSOR BRUCE HALL: Well, I think, um... I don't... I can't 
answer your question any further.

޷֪HumeļȷHumeġBruce Hallԣ
ýΪHumeҽѧԺԺBruce DowtonЮΪʡHumeƴѧķ
ɹʽӦôôǰAdministrative Decisions Tribunal 
оhttp://caselaw.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/isysquery/irl1777/4/doc öUNSW
ķɹĸˡHumeʵʵäUNSW
ķɹʻһֵӦȰHumeδѣѡԺHume
Ȼ̨ķɹȴ˺ͨɡRory HumeԼ
塣

UNSWΪУûеУ˲ŶҪRory HumeJohn 
NilandζCouncil⣬UNSW˱뵽һУ
ܰƽHumęʱý忴 Jeremy DavisȴǸУMark 
Wainwright˺ôһдԸУJohn Ingleson ܽWainwright
ɼUNSWʤУѡضƵС󣬱غҲ
ֻУѡ˳жУְλĿȱС

У֣ڵǿHumeԼ˭Ƿ֮룿
һHumeһȲʣֹ˶˿ȡҲHumeꡣ
ǰHUME˵λAmerican universities tend to be more positive and 
mutually supportiveĴѧƣ໥ ˮ
ůѼ֪ԷѼΪHumeUNSWڶƷȴȼ֮

ʵHUMEҲ˹Ŀ࿴ʱ200312HumeʷԵĶ
HallĽۣ Hume󵼹ڣƺľѵõŵ
Peter Doherty׿ϡȷ֮ʣһŵԣ˭ҹ
ɳBruce HallUNSWˣ쵼ĲHume
Ȼ׾ٵذ˽ǰֻز¶UNSW 
Chancellor John Yu佱Humeľ"Fair, but firm. . Well done.  
ȻǳHumeϾż¶ɡչʾUNSWУ
ˡ

HUMEǣֻҪPeter Dohertyûз֣߰
˵ƣͳ˶֡ǧǣһʧɺNorman Swanƫĺ
ĺһ绰ҵPeter Doherty

Some parts of the media have suggested that Australian Nobel 
Laureate, Professor Peter Doherty, was involved in the report. Peter 
Doherty was sufficiently concerned about the coverage, that he wanted 
to set the record straight. I spoke to him last week about it.

Peter Doherty: Well I was a bit surprised to be part of the public 
event, so to speak, because my involvement in this has been quite 
minimal, and Ive not looked at any of the material on the case or 
even been very aware of it, quite frankly.

Norman Swan: What has been your involvement?

Peter Doherty: Well Rory Hume, whom I know, gave me a call and 
asked if I could recommend some reviewers for the charges that had 
been made, but didnt go into any of them, and in fact he asked me 
first whether I would get involved and I said I just didnt have time. 
So I suggested some names of people I thought might help him, because 
Im aware that Rorys not an immunologist. Particularly I suggested 
people who were retired because I thought they could give the time to 
it. That was it, and then a few weeks later, or a bit after that, Im 
not sure how long it was, Rory called back and just said hed 
consulted the following people, did I know them and did I think they 
were appropriate, and some of the people I knew quite well and I 
thought they were fine, and others I just didnt know them and told 
him. And thats the extent of my involvement. I formed no opinion on 
the case, Ive never looked at any of the material, I never even 
discussed it with anybody seriously.

Peter DohertyHall֪飬͸¶Rory Humeѧң
ʵڷͬСɡԴ͸¶BrennanĽ۶Hall Bruce Hall
ͬǾͿʼ룬˵BrennanСûѧңѧҾûʸ
۶Hall ָأHumeHallվҲǽһ֮ϡ
ȻˣʵUNSWָɵĵHallѡûһ
ѧңJohn Ingleson John Niland Mark Wainwrightҽѧ
մߣΪƫ̻HallǵĽBruce HallRory HumeȫЦɡ
ˣǱˣBrennanСȴѧ̩Gustav Nossalѡģ
ʱÿұֽϢBruce HallӭBrennan顣

Rory HumeһֱԼѧ˵ãԨԷBrennan
档ƭִԭHumeֻǸðѧңHumeHallľ
ԭ޸ݣҽѧԺʮλڣ˵ӵ24ָHume
ܻѧУsevere and irreparable damage to the reputation of the 
university  ˼Norman SwanС࣬Rory HumeŴң
룬ڴУıϵԲ˵Rory Humeĵ̨Bruce 
Hall޹ϵʵϳHallԵHumę

ѼֹһԼİʦCouncilƹʱʾ֧Humeǳ
ʾʵǹ֯ģĿǰ֧ɢ۵Macquarieѧ
ʦAndrew FraserǸᣩΪHumeͬʦн19Ҳ¶
ˮˣҸRory Humeĳȫкñ⻰İ
ʦֻȫУʦͷİʦȷHumeٹ⣬UNSW
߶Humeĺô

Ϊ˭Ϊ˭

ˣԼѸеġܶHumeҲñҲãҵ£
ֵΪHume˷ʱ䣿˽ֲֹHumeһ˵ǰ䲻
ңŭ䲻ҺαһҪȥUNSWУMark Wainwright
HallвҲͬǲɲ

˵θڵȴǼݴѧЩһΪԼЩȫ¶
ۣʵҲǺHumeȱˡӵöˣ
Nicolas Tilney, Professor of Surgery, Harvard Medical School and 
Director, Centre for Transplant Research Brigham and Womens Hospital 
 ȵѵı: He also said As far as performing 
experiments in different countries is concerned, Professor Hall does 
stated this clearly in the first paragraph of his Materials and Method 
section in papers one and two. Professor Tilney is mistaken. There 
are no such indications. BRENNAN  58ҳ  Nicolas Tilney
David SachsһǱȼݴѧʤһĹڣЩﻹһ˿һ
ѧרҵ˸

ݴѧ Humeʰ赻׻˵²ʶ»
ҰHumeǰJohn NilandһȡNilandȻDowtonֻ
ΪHallѣԾ֯顣Ʋһƣֻ׼
Brennan СνDowtonûܽġƼ顱νϼ޻Ϊ
Dowtonûоκξġûܽ顱ֽšNiland
ȫDowtonInglesonı棬в԰ȫƸ
NilandýHallϡʱʤHume෴
ɲHall֮⵫ȴҪԡ顱ҪսBrennan
鱨棬ҪýƵƵ࣬ʵǡùǿͷ

οNilandͨ Bruce HallԶNewcastleѧѧ
԰صö࣬ڹϵӰҲö࣬NilandͨICAC (The 
Independent Commission Against Corruption )ͷͷIrene Mossϵʹ
ICACUNSW׷UNSWһˡҪ֪NewcastleѧΪû
ͨһѧ԰ײICAC˾˷롣Humeƺ
ΨһĿɽֻнBrandon Nelsonѱ

HumeļMark WainwrightWainwrightֻڱƲ
ʱHallڵ̨һΡΪWainwrightԼHallв岻ף
дŵNHMRCHallѱĿоҪʾHallû
Ҳͬʱ֤ȥHallҲûļơֻABC̨õ
ʱһĿWainwrightĺ¡WainwrightһЩ֪
ѧߡǵĶ֧˭ָ˵HallòµNHMRC

WainwrightɫزЩֱԵCouncilԱԼ
CouncilûٸHallWainwrightָʹɸѡHall
ļUNSWվ϶ֲκ˵ʾHallѾ˽ˡ
Wainwright徲УƽȡRory HumeԴӲ
Hall֮찲ӣ

Hume ҽѧԺԺBruce DowtonDowtonٱ߲ѧ
ЦBruce HallûѶԸ difficult staff ȵ
Brennan湫ٱ߲ѧĶԷ֤DowtonԼ֪
޳ܣûԸdifficult staffĴҲӦԼϣ
ԼһĶ⡣Dowton֪ٿĪ磬ȴý
ΪԼ绤ֻBrennan 档Hume֪ôιΪ
Dowtonѣ˸ǷֻΪ࿪ڡֱ䵽òѧý
϶ڣϲ²ͳȫʧHumeHallΪacademic 
misconductscientific misconductҪ misconduct
ʱȴ˵ȻʱǱ֪

DowtonĹ֮ʾΪϼƵ˵ȹҹɣ
ְ֮˽֮Ȼ׼ְ˭˼
ȥDowtonȵֻ˲һꡣԴ˹֮HumeDowton
ӡ

HUMEǷֻ֮ܿϵĹϵֻ
ݴѧHUMEһ뿪۵UNSWѧǳˮ
ƽֻǰһáûѧУHumeеһʱHumeⲢ
ЩѧУ顣ڵֵ˵ǵӸңǼݴѧı
Bruce HallֻUNSWķգմHumeĹݴѧҲBruce Hall
Ҳ˲֮Ե 治֪ʲôֵüݴѧЩһ

ѼΪUNSWHume̫Ϊ򱧲ƽʵʱUNSWHume
̫ ȥ·У԰ڴ˵HumeѰ Humeı·
ԼԴѧɶȫ¡Խ֮ʱHume Ҳݴѧ
չ־ҪһƥԻͷݵĺHume޹ȴֲѧ
DowtonԸְкƹ

¹һ룬ݴѧķ֣Hume
ǰݡ߸߹ ѾǶֻ̫̫ǰ̫ʮ̫
֮࣬ҹʲֻUNSWУʱһ룬ʵǺҳݡHume˵Ӧ
ʹ˼ʹβˣóϴˢǰܣýϴΪԼ
ʵá

ǰ St James Ethics CentreıһHumeְɲסʵ˷
һʵ˵ˣSt James Ethics Centreֲǹٷ˭ϸǮͰ
˭άû̹St James Ethics CentreҲһʽĸ
ѹ UNSWҳйBruce Hallļֻ׼׼ӡ
ΨSt James Ethics Centreӡǹʲô
NEWCASTLE ѧѧ԰St James Ethics CentreУϴˢһɶ
ICAC鲻ҿ˺ĻHUMEְڼȫSt James Ethics 
Centre׮⣬St James Ethics CentreҪǲHUMEԼй
ţ֮ӣ˭St James Ethics Centreд棿

οSt James Ethics Centreı濪壬ƲںյĲ
Ǽ٣һΪݣıʵҲաˣUNSWSt 
James Ethics Centreԭʼ沢⣬St James Ethics Centreֻ
˼µʱ޸ı棬ֱUNSWܹܡòŴСΪʲôSt 
James Ethics CentreıԹؼ¼ֲֻᣬHungerfordָ
Ķʮ֤ʵԵ´Bruce HallָUNSWδ֮ࡣ
ΪRory Humeݴ˵St James Ethics Centreıʵ
Humeݵġ

HumeдǵطʹڣʲôҪHallԴΪ֤֤
HallľضǹġΪʲôUNSW Rory HumeҪܲ
Bruce HallҪһǡ̲ϴ򡱡λֱԲ䣺
췢Bruce HallϣͿܷϡUNSWβ
ָسȻһУա

һĪݵأȻHUMEδ
ἰIan McKenzie˵÷ǳ¶ǡMcKenzieֻBruce HallǵĿ
ѧҡٱ㡣McKenzieؿ֤ݾһҧBruce Hall޹
У԰һţһλѧдУģУҪһζ
Bruce HallΪٱҲUNSWԱʹ֤˾ٱܸҲͬ
UNSWȻУͬλѧߵĹ۵㣬ΪٱǻҲUNSW
йϵ

ȻҲϽͶԣԭֻHumeԼֻ֪
Ĳ²⡣ҲHume˵ʵʱǲòͶء
Ҳ˻HumeHallʵֻΪ˱Bruce DowtonҪȻΪʲô
DowtonڱƹʱУ칫HumeԣΨǧ ˵
HumeΪDowtonĴ߲ŵУʵHumeHallڽǡ
UNSWһ˵ȫƭ̸֮ҪԸϹӪ֮ͨȺò
ƫƫֵǣڽǡ֮˵ͺ͵Ԭ뵱ʵ۵ȴҪˡȰ
һԼһӶѡ

ѼΪݴѧΪRory HumeUNSWҵΪѧ
УǾˮˮɣʵڿUNSWΪʲôҪͽݴѧUNSW
ȻѾˣѧУ֮⣬ںݴѧ
HallʹUNSWɨأUNSWϾһʵʵڵľʵ壬ѧѣѧ
λѧṩҵᣬ˭ָHallΪ
Hume˵Ҳ򣬶ΪHallʵǨ˵ҲԤ㣬ʹЩ
г룬ѧܱUNSW£

ԵӹStephen LynchBruce HallҪ̣: I 
think in this process theres been lots of victims and no winners. 
Australian public included.Ϊһڶܺߣ
޹ûӮ ⻰ Ż֮ӡStephen LynchΪ
ңȻϵӡʵStephen LynchAlex BishopRob 
Loblay֮ԭδʶ֧Bruce HallΪһٳ
ϽݾIan McKenzieBruce Hall֮оʱž
صãѧͶʱҲһԾŶ  2002The Journal of 
ImmunologyѾ֪Bruce Hallѧթƭо˺Ƹˣ
ΪBruce HallBrennanС ˵The Journal of ImmunologyԳ
ϵ13Ӱ־һ׹ڣĺôǲԶ

ӮҵȻMark WainwrightٱȻӮһͷ¶棬
þԶ֮˭ҵùǣBruce HallһЦ
硱治֪δȥ ȴHumeDowtonĽֵȻʼϲ
ġٱǵķѱϾHumęҪȻMark Wainwright½
UNSWУְλԵ˵ԽWainwrightĸУְλԴ
ƣټDowtonճԺְλʹһܵʵݣν
Īɡ

Bruce HallȻıȱȸټϡèһʵԭ
ԼôȫҲøHumeŵ
Hall꣬б¹ԱòĽʵҶΪ
ʾ֭ʹ˻ⲻ˲ʱ¸ڣ˵ֻ˵Hume
ǶHallΪĽBruce HallҿUNSW̨Ļһ
ˡҺ㷽ҵǳĻᣬֱùڿۻңɷ
൱ųꡱһʱȫ˶˵ĳڣԲ˶˵
ΡеʲΰǵĵȻRory Humeݵú䰧Թֱ

ĿƪҶζĵ٩Ķǰڶ׼ų
ѧΪȻκΣ;˵֮ܶҲ֮
ԴҲ档ȻϽѧģõĲҲͲһһע
ĸȤBruce HallΪĿѼ UNSW
HUMEʷ֮һ ṩ˺ܶϢҲunsw, bruce hall 
scientific misconductȹؼһѣ׼ò

UNSWHallΪЦϣʵUNSWͶͬѧûбҪԴ˹
ڻIan McKenzieԺīStephen LynchҡʿAlex Bishop
Rob Loblay켣ϤѧRory HumeݴѧȣDavid 
SachsNicolas TilneyǵصĹˡHall󲢷UNSWУ
Уܸѧ峵Ÿ߰˶ѵҲӣɳ
£˲Rory HumeUNSWHallΪѻˣ˭ʸ
ЦUNSW췹οUNSWڶĽڸҹָRory HumeΪѧ
У˲

ȻΪUNSW֮ӣҲΪBruce Hallڵң
UNSWһѧУڹϵʧܡRory HumeǰκδHall
һޣһֳһʽ
NHMRCICACͣThe Journal of Immunology
Ĭݣ֧֣ Rory HumeUNSW˵Rory Humeʮ
飬Bruce DowtonǵصУмݴѧڶҪ
˳HallʾĻϵдͳϰף£˸񣬼
ֵ˼άʽȷĳЩʵȱݣǽڰ޻UNSW

UNSW Chancellor John YuѾΣµε Chancellor David 
Gonski̽졣ܴҶֻнHallUNSW޴
ѧؽȻѵDavid GonskiĻһţ
ҲѹRory HumeԹˣΪԼΪBruce HallΨһ߹
ļƷ߷߲ƽʵǷѼBruce Hallϵʹ˿
۽磺ѧթƭԭڹһͬתƣѲָUNSW
޻УƾԶûʵѧʹ
ǹ 

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

λڸʲôNSFC򱨵

ߣScience

һֱڴصݣǡ׳ˡ

ҵԴڹһίNSFCһڼ򱨡Ϊ˽Լʱ䣬
Ҽһ¡

ҽѧձڣôдţǸھ̫ίˣ
αˣڵҽѧУҲˣ ¡͡Ρ
У20012002ֱȻѧĿNogoNTFs
Դ޸õоĿ׼ţ30100173͡βƷ
޸˵ʵоĿ׼ţ30200340NSFCˣ
֡


http://xys.3322.org/xys/ebooks/others/science/dajia6/jianbao.txt

ߣ
http://www.nsfc.gov.cn/nsfc/cen/00/its/jiandu991013/20050818_01.html

ǰ˵һЦйֻʵңûҡΪ
õκһòܷ飬йпܷ
ֱʵ塣ձȻѧΩ𺳣
ŵĴ⣡

NSFCʱ鱨ѧλαðǩαĿо
ԱĿԱĹоȷṩϢ
гϮ顢ѧɹαѧݣα
ءҵλߵ֤

ڻĿʵʩУδ涨оְʵʩα졢۸о
Ϯ˳ɹһͶʵŲáÿѧ𾭷ѵȵ

ţë˵ٵİٷֱȣʵ̫ձˣͬڵļ
ҲԿܶ൥λΪ˸ԼôЩһǲŲʡ
ձе˵黹̫дˣϾҵĳ
ֻ걨ĳ̶ȣ

ҵǣ˭ܸսڵĹλҽѧ¼
Ľɫʲô

NSFCվϷݣ

еλԹ涨ʱڣ齻еλй
ţеλʵԵȽˡеλڹ涨ʱڣҪ
ͳһȻѧᡣȻѧ᲻ύ롣
http://www.nsfc.gov.cn/nsfc/cen/sqzn/02ss/01.htm 

ʸҪʽƸĿеλһӦǸĿе
λڱʽְƸƸԱȣÿеλʱ䲻
6¡http://www.nsfc.gov.cn/nsfc/cen/sqzn/02ss/01_01.htm

֪ǷΪȫɵλˣλ
ǲǱʾʵ

ҵȷôҲһ⣺սڵλڸ¼Ӧ
еʲôNSFCලίԱȻڼֻδֵλ̬ȣǴ𣿴
֣ҺġϼġԿѧвΪĴ
취ҲжԵλĴʮ
http://www.nsfc.gov.cn/nsfc/cen/00/its/nsfc990916/20050526_001.html
֪¼ǲڵһĿ߻е߷Ϊ
ڹΣôӦظ̸ѡ澯ڲͨ
ѵôڵһΪߡ¡͡Ρ
ͲڣҲƿģôûȷ
飬λûйôôдսҲûݵģΪ
ǡ¡͡Ρƾʲôϲûеսڣ

ϣ˸Խ󣬶л

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

ʦһҫ

һ

ĺ֪뿪ǰżڱ϶ƪأԭ
λսؼߡġҵŵסв֡ʱͶед
ϰߣҲĳϸЩɡ磬60ǰձ԰³ѷ
Ȼ͵ϮŭΥϣս򡣡Ȼʦ
³ѷˡָ͵Ϯ֮ʹ׼ȷ˵
³ѷˡӦðӢˡӢҲսָ͵Ϯ
ۣǾֻΪˣһص̨תĿ϶ѯϾѧ
ʷϵ߻ڴᷨǷ׼ȷԻ³ѷָͨӢˡ
˵׼ȷԭܸӡһ桱˻֮ʺݾӹ⣬Ҳ
δлѧ̡

ıֽزôһ֡ǣʾ˰С
ûձǩ֤УΪһδʹձйߣ
֪Լûʸع˵ġڰ˶սսǰȥ
Ҿձ2003꣬ҰѰ˶սսĲɷüƻַѰ
һγ뾳ǩ֤ҲɷС¡פĻ
Jean-Raphaelر֤ŵ׵½ΪŮСʲվϣ
ˡʩ޵ǡĺӰӢʹݾáսؼߣƽߡ
³ѷɼʦҲûз롮³ѷҲָӢ
-עıϣҰǩ֤CCTVСƬҪҵա
浵ձʹΪ棬´Աһˡص
ֻǰװæһ࣬ʱһûСרձͶ
Ӵ˵ⶼƾ500ǰ˽ӣʾ˰С
ûձǩ֤

ȻˡΪһδʹձйߣ֪Լûʸ
ع˵ġĳϿңͨѯʦǡ˵ġˡд
սôܲձݳ˽ʦȥԺպ͸Լй
һЩ£ʷĲֻ֣ЩʶɲꡣԼûʸ˵Ļ
ǲ˵˵ôŷһźá

ʦȻˡڰ˶սսǰȥĹҾձԸ
Ϊһְҵߣ֪Ϊʲôû뾡취ҲȥһΣ
ƾոԼ¡έϯһµ޾롱Щѽ⡣
Աȡࡱʾ񫣬ƺδɡȴûи
ǩ֤ԭΪձʹСȱ˵ġ
ǿԼձʹȻӣʹȴǸ𷢷ǩ֤ġֻ
ʼǲû˵ԼǷύǩ֤򹫻˽
򹫣ΪٷýȻ»²ȥ򾭰ѯ
ʣ˽ôԷѻʲôԭձʹҳ϶
ϸ˵˰10գ7վ֪û
ȥûаѻսȥʹдһεʣҲ֪
ǩ֤

ʦйعύ˲ɷüƻϣɡǣ
ûκһһҪԼʱ뷨Ȼ
Դ˵ձ˲ԸйȥձдԼսܵĳ衣Ҳ
ʹݹԱһսؼʲô˲ġձͨѶ
ͱļ߳ڰˣһɼȫԷƴܵ
ң˼Ҽ಻˰ɡ

Ĺųʦʱ13֮ʦĵ6飬Ҳ
ġʦӦó13ʱﲻȫΪⱾдɡ
13ѪҲȷʵֵ̫áΪ»ߣõǹӣܻ
ɱĹ»ʦô˿ݣǲֻҪ
»ֻҪԼ»ģ˽أ⣬
ʦһ飬ɼдҪܱ֮ͣȡ

ӦʹĵسϣΪϵ֮ʣʦǰĸгԾ˿
ͷһ㣬ҲãҲãŶͬ顣˵ĸ
ãһϾѾͨĽһȺռ
иԴƵĵλοƼڱҲȨݣ
ũᵽǮյԭձ糤˵Щ
ΪʦдУǱϻʵ϶ɷ϶
һԴԳԱһڶгʵϣȴ޴ҫԼ
Ժպｻ֮С

ȥũʱ˽̽ǩ֤ΪԵʱʦ»
פĴҵʵʵڵĲȫûбҪ
ԼЩոձҵıѧѧһҪֵЩ
һΰǩ֤ѧѧοѵʦû𣿻ֻ
ԱᣬȻͨʹǩ֤Աһսؼߵ壬ʾʵǺ˲ġ
뾳ʱԱֲӵѶһʦ
ŸءΪڻŪԼһô˲йߣ
ֿԴһˣ

⣬Ԫ˵ġ֢˶šĻǲá
һΪԼ֢Ǹŵˣеϣյſˡ
ΪͬУѺõһ

ʦҲǬΪʦܿϧǬѾţܴ
Ƿôһѧ֪ʦ˼ָǬôһ
ӣ˵ʦ˼Ǭ飬Ǳһ˶ȥǬҰݷ˼
Σ

˳˵һ㣬ĵڡ뿡ġŵʧʦͬС
ᵽ//ۨ⣬»縱ܱʤ٣Ҳǳ
ǹֵĿԮԽսսؼߡʱʦŻǸëӰɡ

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

УУϢƽ̨ʧܵһ֤ط

ģ


Դӽ·֪ͨҪѸУBBSĽɡУϢƽ̨
δBBSͳֻеĴѧBBSڶ԰쿪ٹرˣδ
һȫʡ

дУУϢƽ̨Ľʧܵġһģз˵
ڵδBBSУںУ֮ϢվϽѧ¥ɱ
¼δBBSѧ֮нУϢҲи档
ˣУһֽǣɱ¼˵ʾп
ʹɱȥʵʩɱΪ⵱ȻǲģͬʱҲɣʹ
ֹBBSۣѵѧûͨ;֪¼𣿼ֹ
BBSۣȷǼϢɢһ;ܲЧ
ͨжϾͿ½۵ģҪʵʵĵ顣ƾ˽
Ϊ񡶱¾ƽý壬ڶɱ֮¼дĵı
֮Ϣ򱱴ѧɢЧʣBBSۣܶ˺ܿڱȽ϶
ʱڣͬʱBBSƽýϻ֪Ϣġ

ͬʱΪͻ¼ѧУһʱչȫУΧڵ
õƽϢѧͿֻŵİ취Ǹṩһߵĳ
ͨһ̶ȵķйѹⱾǡУϢƽ̨
ˣBBSֻдʹɱɱĿܣҲмǵɱĿ
ܡЧӦֵøԣȻҲҪڽܵóۡûм
ʵ֤ʱΪܵĴڣͽֹۣǰҲɱˣһ
ġϵ

ھֿԾٳһӣ֤Уͻ¼ȫͨ;
ѧ֪

82223ʱ52֣ѧδBBSǵذ淢ģΪֻļ˼
ƿӣͱʡ´˵һƶѧڻûõѧʱΪ
˻һ¾ѣڱ˶ƿ⵽֪
ȫ๤ѱаƿӷ¡ƪۣΪյ
ʮŻ֮һ

ֹһ죬824յġԡƶƿٳ
ı⣬һ¼16ʱ16֣
ϡȷ߶ߣһϢǴδBBSϿġ

ȿ˵δBBSûпʣûֹУ
˽ÿյBBS̬ĿԺܶ࣬磬߿֮ͨ
ֶͻƷֱӵ½δBBSͨϵӱѧÿյBBS
̬ܾܿڱְıѧдɵģȵȡ

޶żǰ¾ڱ¥ǡ̵ı
УҲᵽδBBSϱϵѧ¶ģҲΪʮ
⡣ɼδرպ󣬼ʹЩʼBBSһʼҲֻBBS
۵Ļ⣬ҲȻԱƽý߻֪ΪⱾѾǶԡУ
Ϣƽ̨ķ̡

ѾһƽýϢ򱱴ѧɢЧʣܲBBS
ۡʵϣƽýϢֱ򱱴ѧɢҿԼӵ
ѧɢתءı֮󲻵Сʱ20ʱ59֣
ϢתصһBBSϡһǼڹϵBBSΪԱ
ٺȥ걻ɱһͿBBSйһʵûȺУѧ
ռһֹдʱΪֹתڣȻֻ˲
ۣ˶ǱѧȻѾͨδBBSϵԭʼ£ͨ
תصһϵδԭĵ֪˴£룬ܻܿбѧͨ
һʲŵһλ֪µġ

һ֮⣬ĹBBSsopaiȫȣһ
ƣһͿر֮վģûȺжһıѧͨЩ
BBS֪δϵĶ̬ѧҲ൱Ŀ

Ҫ֮һBBSԴϢĴ̣ͼʾ


šة
δBBS ءƽýýȹBBS 
ЩϢЩЩЩ



ȱѧةة




ɴ˿ɼֻҪϢδBBS;ܱϣѧԾɿͨ
;Ϣδؾ͵ϢǰǣԽһɱ
BBSɱý塢ɱƽý塣ƶƿӱС¼ˣ
ѧɱ˺ɱĴ¼ҲˡҲͽһУΪ˷ֹ
ʾɱδBBSϵ۵ʵ塣

ѾڡУУϢƽ̨Ľʧܵġһָδ
BBSĳɡУϢƽ̨֮BBSӦеܼ޷ʵ֡ڿ
УϣͨƻۼٸʾĹҲ̫ʵ֣֤
˸УУϢƽ̨Ľȷʵʧˡ

2005.08.25

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

Ҳ˵СĸԺǶǿˣ

yanchen

ˡСĸԺǶǿˣƪºҲ
ߵĹ۵㡣

Ҫһ£λۡʿʮа˾ֻڹڻҽѧ
ѧλȻܵðMDȥƭ⡣˼ǣһЩҽҽʿ
ѧʿѧλûУ󣬾ȻҲö֮سԼΪMD

ȻĿǰѾֲ֣ȻΪҲһֵΪ
Ŀǰ˵(90%)Ĺҽ˹ⶼԼMDı
ǩЩڹڻҽѧʿѧλˣ򼸺һټһ
PhDγһֺܾйɫMD,PhD

ͬʱҲ˵ǶΧй
ѧôMD+PhDеܾȡҵĽͺŻȻ򡣵ȻΪ
йˣҲ˵Щ٣ֻýΪסˡ

֮ÿοǵЩйڼбԼMD,PhDͬ
Ӭ

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

ڡ͢һ284¯Ȼδ𣿡ȶ

ߣӺ



ڡ˿վϿ޵ѵ¡͢һ284¯Ȼ
δ𣿡Сݳʶ϶Ǹš

ţҺʱı˹ġȤζѧйص
googleһ£Ȼҵص֡οԵ
˿վϣԱչۡ

Ƿ284³20ӣҲ֪ǲǿܡƾʶ
ܶϣ϶ܣδϡ

ϱ˹ġȤζѧ½ڣ
http://www.pep.com.cn/200406/ca446192.htm

ܵסߵ

ȵһҪǿöࡣϷס¶ȣ
ס´Ϊ޷ܵ¶Ҫߵöࡣв¶ڱ
ĵطߵ46϶ȣ55϶ȡִӺ캣ʻ벨˹
ʱ򣬴Ȼϵرŷ磬¶Ȼߵ50϶ϡ

ϣȻ¶ȣûг57϶ȵġ޼
һСȡĵطⶨйߵ¶ȡ

ղ˵¶ȶڱġ˳һ£ѧΪ
ʲôϲڱϲ¶ȡԭֻзڱ¶ȼƲ
Ĳǿ¶ȡ¶ȼƷ£̫ͻɹñΧ
ȵö࣬¶ȼָĶͲΧ¶ˡ÷
¶ȼ¶ȣһҲûеġ

Ѿʵ鷽ܹܵ¶ȡԭڸĿ
Χ¶ȼߣ˲סˮ¶ȣ100϶ȣ
ʱסߵ¶ȣһֱߵ160϶ȣӢѧҲ
Ϊʵ飬ȵ¯ͣСʱ֤ݡ
Ҳָͣڿ¶ȵ켦ţŵķ
ǿ԰ȫ޺ġ

ôΪʲôߵأԭʵǲ
¶ȵģŽӽµ¶ȡôķֿ¡
ˮʱܴӽƤһȡȣʹ¶ȴ
͡Ҫܹܸ£ΩһҪǣ岻ֱӽӴԴ
ҿ

йľ飬ʢ¶ȴﵽ30϶ϣ֮÷¶ֻ
20϶ȷܡԭȻڻ÷ʪȸߣʢĵʪȱȽϵ͡

Ȥζѧ

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

޳ܵĽڣ޳ܵĹԱ

ߣbeihe

ˡһԱļѧ(XYS20050824) ̾

йɲҪữ֪ʶǺöٵһ
ü꣬ ת֮䣬 ö쵼˶ʿʿѧλ еһУ
һĿģ ùĸ̸Ǯ ޳ܵĹš йĽ磬 
ν֪ʶӣҲٿ ǮλνĲ˵Ļ˵Լ
ĲʿڶʿڼӦвˮƽˡ ⲻ޳ܣʲô
¼


ƶûϹֱӶʿڶʱСˮƽҷɣ

Enlighten


缸ڸУоо仰

ǵٺð˹ԺȱʲôͲʲôٱλ޼ɣ

ҹڤ룩

Ҳں˻Ϸܿˡ
ˣûУ

2005329գݴѧԲ԰ɣΪ
ùǶ̬ۡʷĻֵܱ߻ƻϷܿ

ڡǵ
ܲдǾƳˮʦɡ

bingo

(XYS20050825)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info)

һΪ˰޷˿վĹ˽˿վĶ̬ؿ
˿ʼбxys@yahoogroups.com

ʼбÿ췢һ˿վ¸µϣÿµ׷һÿ
Ŀ¼ʼбĶμ롰˿֮ѡ
ʼбxys_friends@yahoogroups.com

ù䶩ġù䣬ܿ޷յ
Ƽ䣺yahoo.com, hotmail.com, gmail.com

ġ˿ʼбĵ䷢һհż

xys-subscribe@yahoogroups.com 

塢ͣ˿ʼбͣ䷢һհż

xys-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com 

Ͷxinyusi@yahoo.comôıļͶ塣

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.dyndns.info) 
