                         ˿µϣ20061227գ

06.12.26ûи
06.12.27, ӡƫôġ
06.12.27, 󷡶Ϊʲô˵ǻ֮١š
06.12.27, ѧԺС桶뿴JPIB(ֲѧ)ǵϹƽеè塷
06.12.27, Фӥԡйѧ¼ĸ
06.12.27, JeromeλѧҿԼҽҩ
06.12.27, ľӡݸĿʰš
06.12.27, ֡Ϊ
06.12.27, ̸̲¡ߡΪʲôôǣ
06.12.27, yjyylzbg޴ڡ
06.12.27, 졶ʮʿǶ˶ˣ
06.12.27, ܷɳǡƷɺ裬ҮգαѧʥӸС
06.12.27, Ϳѧоռìء
06.12.27, ѧͺõļݵȴ
06.12.27, ϼһο͡Sam Harrisһ֮šиС

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

                       ƫô

                         ӡ

    ΪдҪҰѡݸĿһ飬һЩȤĶ
Ȿ˼壬ӦռҩΪʵȻҩֳˮ
ʯݡȡˡľ桢ۡ顢ݡޡ˹ʮ
ﶼȥˣѹ˳֮ΪŴٿȫ顣

    ٿȫ鲻ͬǣݸĿҩ飬Ŀ
Ϊβ˿ɡ´ͷŲ
¡Ьϯظҷȡϯǡ
ɨ㡢޳ͰճƷΪ˽ǵճ;
Ϊ˵ճɻһ֭ʲôļڽ쿴ѵȤ


    ݸĿ¼ĺܶҩȻνƫԴʱʱͼ
۽֤Чԡڡˮ˲ͬʱµˮβͬ
޸һˮͬƲ֢СЧʱ
˵ǡȡʼ֮Ҳ

    ݸĿ˶Ʋ֢ƫеı⻹Ҫ棬һ
ǣԪʱ͵ҵյڴ£˻СΪʲôأûнͣ
Ҳ˰˼⡣еƫûнͣǿԲ³Եɡݡ
Ŀ˵֭ճɻҺˣǵ¡ûи
ݣΪȻܹ㣬֭ҲҲڻ°ɡ
    صƫʱȻŲɣһ̾˵
ϵˣϵճɻңˮܹο񲣬̾۴
Ƨ֮޲ߣԲ֮ʿ

    ЩβġƧ֮ֻǳĳ˵쿪
Ҳ֤СЧǾͳ˾̸֮Ͼڲе
пɻеģпͻȻõģҲпںˮ
˻֮ȥģպЩƫΪЧ֤ݡƫ
ЧʱȻ࣬ǵڼסЧĸ棬ȴ
ЧΡصĻʧҵ

    ƫЧΪձΪ༲
ʾ£ƫõҩԽƧԽϡ
ãԽۻԻߵʾþԽǿЧҲͻԽá
ϬǡǡޡܵҲΪҩݸĿ¼˴
ĻҩţеˮϴˮĥˮˮˮЬ
ʬڣࡢȮࡢӵࡢࡢ
žʳѸͷȵȶθָļšҩ
ڲҲſڵĶڲҩˡͬšԶ
ԶҲͱΪⶾҩ

    ݸĿѹǡ˲˵˵϶Ǳͷͷʺ
ϥͷצסݡʺ֭ˮѪҺҺݹ
롢ë˹ǡǡ¡ơ˵ȵȶҩ
ҩЧ

    Ȼй˾رŹ֣ĹŴҽҲˣд
ڰϡۻࡢж֮ﵱҩ⣬ԵӦֻͬݸĿ
ⲿٿȫ顱ЩȫռһԲԵøͻ

    û˻񶨡ݸĿ¼˹ıͷ³Ѹ
ҲΪⲿ顰зḻıءûоѧľδؿɿ
ֻԶﴫ˶ǰ˵ľ̸֮˵ţʱ˻ĵ
زʹؽ˹˾ĿɽֵЩŹֵƫ
ڿԲ˼ط񶨡ؼǶЩȥôŹֵƫ
أҩЧһŷϡǲǵģж롢
ﴫжǱƾ飿ҪȥĴ֡αôһܵ
棬һѵʹ

2006.12.22.

й걨2006.12.27.

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

Ϊʲô˵ǻ֮
	


(http://antipseudoscience.googlepages.com)

ԡдΪ£񣬹ǰ޲׼ʳ
衣ǣÿߵʱ򣬶ǵβ
ɵķ⽨£Ǿ͹Цһɢǹ۲2006
ĩⳡССġȡαѧᷨǩ˶ʱѷƵ
һĻݣΪӭʶ̬ǰѡĻ֣
ͳĻ裬ʶ̬Դǵʱȴ
ǵβСαѧ£ǹЦϹۡǵǩ
ȥϾͿһˣΪֹٷûκαʾһ
ûУҪ˵ͣȴظ˶ԣ
ǵͷһˮ

Ĺŷʱӡӡ˾ϵναʿ
ڵͷѵˣԼͬáơԡα
ʿһΪԼĻΪ⣬ȡαѧᷨ롰ȡ
ᲢۡôΪʲôҪ˵ⳡǩǻ֮أ

ǽڵġαѧɹⷴɺһ
ıҼȾ֮£γơѵ˹ѵͷʱ򡱣ճ棬
ȻһʮıǾӦٱҰȫ
ŶԣùҰȫշƲвıġĵ
ⷴ͹ĳЩѧԣȴѡùŵʽ¶
ȷһıôǡݾߡ˵ͨ籨ţ
ûı˾ټݺѪˣΣǲȡġ
Ⱥߡ˶ǹظɣԼΪŻһ¾÷
αѧ˶Ӵ伣Ϊ̬Ц

ǷɱˣӦô죿跨
͹ɱ˴Ӷ׼ȷַΪǺȡ̷С
κһͷѵ˶ѵóۡͬ˴
αѧСͳĻ֮ʵŬαѧ봫ͳĻ
֮ϵȡαѧᷨǵ
ҲѵóۡǡǡȺ̵˸ˡȡαѧᷨ
飬鲻Ц

ŹˡΪ֤ӡӵˡͼй
ͳĻǲϧνսԵĿƼԭԳɹѧ
ڴͳĻ塣ǣνġαѧԩ
ǵġѧɾ͡롰ͳĻйأǡȫϢѧǡѶ
ɡǡƷѧڶɡѧʿӻġѧ
Ǻ͡ͳĻЩԨԴ̫ϵھŴǶѲˣԤ
ԵġʮǡְڣҲ˵ԤԵġľǡĹ
նɶ㲻ˣַĸʱ췴ùͷļ淶췴
Ϊ˵Դ췴ɾдֱ˵Ĵõúܡһ
㷴Դͱɷˡʹ˵ֲַԼ׳
Ц

ģװǻƣſڴƻơӽʧʵǣ
İ߹Ϊ׼йαѧԩ﹥ҽ
׵ȴͳĻɱսԿƼɹѧȡȴʵФ
ڱΪԭ治ʵؿԼõӽ¶
Ȩظ棬ӻȻ롰ͳĻйأҪҲΪԭ
Լõӽ¶ΪȨߣʲô
αѧԩɡصϵ÷ӵ
һϵаߣֻһߣ׳ƣЦ

ĴڲͬĳϱƣҲ̷ȡ
Ҳȷȡˣɼڷȡĳ˵ơֱ
ͽͺͲ԰׵ġκι˴޸ķɵȨ˺ڷ
ȡĳᷨڷɲϵȻ޿ɺǣǣ繫ɲ
ǲ˵ĳЩ˵ĳЩ˵ǺһϷΪǻ
֮١ͨں֪ʶӻԴķѧǹ޸̷ĺ
Ƽٷ޸̷ĺ֮ԱǡĻƺͿЦ֮
ɷѿĵ׫дţõ֪֪ʶӡ
֧֣ǹǩȴʾ֪֪ʶӡʣ
ǩģǸСȦӵˡʶ̬֪֪͡ʶӡ
̸ǲ̫Ķ⣬ԸܹĳЩ

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

뿴JPIB(ֲѧ)ǵϹƽеè

ѧԺС

ڡ˿վ˼ҷпԺˮϹƽѧ
ΪºJPIBֲѧڿгţǲѿ
漸è壺

һϹƽڼΪ永쵼ΡʼȻûеõ
λߵϿɣΪʲôҪϣʵǲһѧΪ

ڶϹƽΪ쵼Ҳõ˻رνĵλ֤У쵼ҲΪ
ͼϹٰƽalthough he has stated that an unauthored visiting 
student was involved in putting the data togetherˣṩ
ݵѧȴûܳΪߣûеõϿɡ쵼ȴΪߣ
ЩݲαģΪǷҲһѧˣ

༭¼õϹƽ˵ĳţȴΪٷ
ûɡԲܸ翯ǡ֪ȷѧ٣ͨ
Ѷʽݵĵӻνġٷ顱զôѣ
߻ܹ㹻ʱÿƼشĿ
http://www.most.gov.cn/tztg/200611/P020061117312512645794.doc

Retraction 
ߣϹƽ  
Shangguan ZP, Lei TW, Shao MA, Xue QW (2005). Effects of Phosphorus 
Nutrient on the Hydraulic Conductivity of Sorghum (Sorghum vulgare 
Pers.) Seedling Roots Under Water Deficiency. J Integr Plant Biol 47, 
421-427. 
The first and corresponding author, Zhou-Ping Shangguan, of the above 
article has requested that its publication be retracted from the 
Journal of Integrative Plant Biology (JIPB), with the following 
statement: With the fact that the data published in the 
above-mentioned article contained plagiarized materials from the 
article of Shen Y, Wang B, Qu D, Chen R. Effects of phosphorus on root 
hydraulic conductance of corn under water stress. Journal of Northwest 
Sci-Tech University of Agriculture and Forestry (JNSTUAF, Natural 
Science Edition). 2002, 30: 11-15, I have to retract the paper from 
JIPB. In addition, I admit that the manuscript was prepared and 
published without the consensus of the other three authors listed, 
therefore, I myself am solely responsible for the plagiarizm and 
falsification. I deeply apologize for the damages to JIPB and the 
authors of the JNSTUAF paper, and for misleading the readers by the 
publication and citation of the data.

Zhou-Ping Shangguan
Institute of Soil and Water Conservation, the Chinese Academy of 
Sciences 
Yangling, Shannxi, 712100, China
Tel: 86-29-87019107
Fax: 86-29-87012210
E-mail: shangguan@ms.iswc.ac.cn
July 16, 2006
 
Editorial
It was brought to our attention that the above-mentioned paper 
co-authored by ZP Shangguan was involved in serious scientific 
misconduct. We communicated several times with the first and 
corresponding author (ZP Shangguan), to allow him to clarify the case 
by himself. We have carefully investigated the case, with help from 
the authors home institution, the Institute of Soil and Water 
Conservation (ISWC), the Chinese Academy of Sciences. On December 5, 
2006, we received a formal statement from the ISWC, that described the 
results of an official investigation into the case. Based on these 
documents, we would like to make the following statements: 
 
1) It is apparent that the above-mentioned paper contains falsified 
and plagiarized data from the following paper: Shen Y, Wang B, Qu D, 
Chen R (2002). Effects of phosphorus on root hydraulic conductance of 
corn under water stress. Journal of Northwest Sci-Tech University of 
Agriculture and Forestry (Natural Science Edition), 30: 11-15. 
 
2) The first author is fully responsible for the misconduct, although 
he has stated that an un-authored visiting student was involved in 
putting the data together. 
 
3) We acknowledge that a formal request was made by ZP Shangguan on 
April 10, 2006, to the editorial office to retract the paper; however, 
the Journal has not been able to publish the retraction letter earlier 
because the investigation was not formally completed. 

4) ZP Shangguan has been discharged from administrative duties of the 
ISWC. 
 
This serves as a reminder to all involved with the Journal that 
scientific integrity requires original research from each published 
author.
 
Journal of Integrative Plant Biology
 
December 11, 2006

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

ý˱ﰲȫ
ԡйѧ¼ĸ

Фӥ

20061211賿ʼĳһƪ¹ѧҳй
ѧڲһбϰٸýתأһϯ
ýġ硣ѧϣһ֡ЧӦ˵ָһֻ
ѷȴеĺȶ³ܺ󣬿¿˹
һ硣Ȼⳡ籬֮Ѹ͡ɨ֮ʵ
ǡЧӦ˵ܽ͵ġЧӦ˵ķѧҰ
ȣԵ˵Ļѧۡţ90
׷ѧʱеĻܸܿǾⳡ
ʾѧۣؽ֮ΪڴЧӦ

ⳡν¹ѧҳйѧų磬
һ֮䣬й޴֪˵¹ѧҹ˱ڡںйѧ
ѧڹȥһڣͨ׷ٿ˶ߵķӦ
֣Ǳʾֹ֧˱򡢻ǷԹ˱򣬼ж߶ȷŹ˱
˵ʼٸߣûʵԡȻʵȴǣ
ĳƪתصġ¹֮ı¹ѧһֻ
й֡ѧй˱Ĺ۵ͻ˱ָժλŮ
Ʒ޷ŴΪ˱йѧҼ
ںйѧĵ

ǣ¼ʼ죬û˹˼¼ࡣ¹ѧһֻ
ۿй֡ѧһģڴ½ʹáGoogleԺܼת
ء˵ýýϷӦĶ߶ûʶ
ԭıҪҲͨ߶ý׷ǿģǣ
źǣ¼ѧߣͬ˶ý׷
šϷһλӰң12ԼĲϷҲͬ⡰
ѧһ˵һģƪͱʾҵȻǲֱִͬ
ġһλصıڣһɷãߵ绰е
򵥽ʾ˱򣩵Ĺ۵̫Ƭ棬ȫ½ۡ
λѧߣһߡһ꣬ڵѧвӰ֪ѧߣ
ǵѧʶ񣬵ýۣʵˣȷź
һ̻

˱һλ30꺺ѧоʷĹĺѧңоҪ
йѧйѧ˱20йѧʷר
ȺϺѧԺ2004йѧ2006ˡ21
йѧ״Ľв20ͺйѧĹ۵㡣
Ҫйѧ˱ԻӦĶͷ
ףеķʸڵȴǣҿѧԹ˱ķԣ
Ķ˱ĶֱӲɷù˱ġ¹֮ߵı
ѧ淶ѧ۵ĻӦӦѧߵıΪݣȻڴý
ŻУǵĻӦȴֱƾýıȱٱҪʶ
еظܵڴýȫţıճ
ϢĽܷʽҲڸıѧķʽ
֮Ѿý黯档¬˵ý˵죬Ҫ
˵ý졣ͳһý黯档

¼һܵĿ˶֮ѽӽڳ䶨ˡ
Ҫ֮һ˭أλĲá
һߴⳡڴЧӦ
ͷλֿļͶŭġʯͷȻ
ǾʹֱȻҮյġͷŮۡ˭ģ˭Ϳ
ŮͶеʯͷ֮һ֮磬
Ϊѷĺиǿĳ򣬶ΪߵĻ
ԼμıǿҵĻӦʮգ·֮ĵ
죬½Ѿɼ¹֮±˱챨ֽҵ
ڱз˹˱±ĵʼȷʾǼ챨ֽ
ȻҵĻҿ϶˵޵˵Ʒ
дģйѧû˵ǣûпԹ˱
ԮֵĶ߻ӦֵעǣǸ
ݷԵļλ֪ѧߣҲûٱﷴ˼Լۡ

ΪýţǵĻ˫壺һ棬
ṫϢϢе˫ƽȺɣһ棬ʹ
ͽȱٹͬﾳʹ˱ﱻԱΣСý
ţԸ˱ĸȡԭʼﾳ˱û
ﾳõ˶С˱ﱻѡڴ˶ϵ˶
ǡԭתءԷչǽˡժҪ༭
дĻ˶˶УԱĶȡԱ
ģǡϷġ

ڴڴϢĻ˶Уһи˱ﶼǲȫġΪ
İȫҪأ˱ͼİȫ˱ıȫ
˱İȫΪڴȡ˸˱ԭʼﾳ˱
İȫͲһԤ趨ģ෴ҪͨǵĹͬŬ
ܵĽȥάġ

ûи˱İȫûи˱ɣûи˱ɣû
дڴĹûдڴĹûкгĹ򡣴
Ρ¼УӦȡĸѵǣҪԴڴ˶и˱
ĲȫѵԾԴڴϢҪɾˣڴ
еЧӦԻ

ԭأл鱨20061220գڶ棬
http://www.gmw.cn/01ds/2006-12/20/content_525265.htm˸ݡй
̳2006ᷢģ

Фӥ廪ѧѧϵڣ100084xiaoying@tsinghua.edu.cn

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

λѧҿԼҽҩ

Jerome

ĩѧ̲ʱżȻһΪѧ飬Ͽ躡

һ鼮ʮص㣬һʲôɫˡ֪ʶϵ
ȣ壬̸ܵĳλӻȺ

漰йŴѧѧҽȵ෽档

Ƚϴ

Ϊ֤Լ۵Ŀѧԣֽͭӡˢ˼Ǯѧɭ
дš

벵⡣

ͨҶһЦġ̫ˡҼһ£һ
漰αѧһŻ;ҲҸõ˽ǵ̩;
ҪǣҵйĽ

ȾȺ!

----------------------------------------------------------------------

ҳȽдԵؽϿ躼Ҫоɹ,Լ
õ֧֡

1.Ͽ躼(http://mainpage.nwu.edu.cn/unit/uzlsx/jieshao.htm)
"Ͽ, , ѧѧо, ȻѧίԱ
ҽҩشоƻרԱ."
...
"1986, ڿѧ̩ǮѧɭĹػ֧, ѧ˼ά
ѧѧйͳĻ(ҽѧ)Ľо. ǮƼ, 
1990ֵõѧ̩ղĹ֧. λ̩ʹԭʼ֮
·1991ɿѧ桶˼άѧۡ,'˼άѧ'"

...

2.ѧϰǮѧɭѧ˼룬ȷԴйͳĻ
(http://mainpage.nwu.edu.cn/unit/uzlsx/qianlao4.htm)
"1985꣬дھƷֵͶУѧ˻д
Ǯѧɭ̶ʶӴһֱĹػּ֧Ŀѧ˼ָ
ѧ˼άѧѧѧйͳĻҽѧĽ
оָоʵķԾ봴ѧƽ׶Σ1991
ѧ桶˼άѧۡ˼άѧ»ͨѶ199512
1'Ͽ躴˼άѧ'Ϊб"

...
"˼ѧȷԴйͳĻǱߴǮѧɭ
õҪʾҲǳɹĹؼڡѧеѧ
۵оʵüֵҲҽ֡'߼ͺͼ鹫ʽ
ϵ'199ʽѧӦóɹ֮һʽϵԴ
һһʢ˥Ƴʢ˥ҩԺ͹ܣ
رǹ龭ԭĲкãƳõҩȿɵӦֵ
Ƴҽ䴦ֿɶҽƷϸѧ֤䲻
֮Ƶ;ʹҽ֤ι淶ʽΪܡˣ'
ѧ֤淶о'2004'973'ƻȻе
ѧ۵оֻǮѧɭղԿ϶Ǯѧɭͬʱָ
˵ľԣǿءȡ侫ȥɡһЩԷ񶨣
Ϊ'⽨'ǮѧɭԴйͳĻ̬ȼԶ׿
ʶɴ˿ɼһߡ"

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

ݸĿʰ

ߣľ ͣhttp://blog.sina.com.cn/u/1024473630

£һ£ĳ˵־ת˱׾ΰ
ݸĿҸ˱ȽϺõۣҡңṩûп
½ڣǳȨժ¼£֮ڼתصݣ

תעڡݸĿЦѾ˵ˣ
ƪ»˵һЩ⡣ҵʱɼھĻ
ɽ屦˵δ֮࣬ΪġݸĿ
ȫУǡ˲ʮڶҳ
ȫժ¼£Ҳ꣺

ǣĿ
⡿ʱԻˣ̿ʱȡãԳ
ӡ֮ϳ塣Ǿɢ
죬ǽڵء侫أΪΪ
ʯĿ׹ػΪʯѪΪΪ֮Ҳ
Ρģǣ߿ĥˮ֮ʱ䡱

Ŀ׹ػΪʯǰߵǺͺѪ󣬻
еףô£˭ר
ֵĲ˵ƫƫЩҾԲҪ񶨡ݸĿʷ壬ʱ
̬ӦϽģʱľޣЩЦԱġ֮
䡶ݡ˵ŴȨȫɿ룬ҵĳӦ
ͬӹڡʷǡ˵һµġ

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

Ϊ

ߣ

һʱ,ӹҽһƬ,Ҳ˵ʲô
ʿǶʿ,ֻ˵Ӿһͨѧ,Լѧ֪
ʶٺԼԽӴҲйһЩѧϰҽ֮,һЩì,˼
Щìܲԭ.Լ֪ʶϵͳ,ִѧʵ
зóԼĽ.

һ,ݵ˾ͱ˷˼,ڸBBS۲,
⼸һЩһЩ,Լͳһ,Էӵռ߳
,˵ķ,ʱЩá!

һʱ,Ҳһֱ˼ҽҽ,ϵĸ,
ҾбҪһԹߵ˵.Ƕµļ
ߵĵ˵

1,ǿ,ֱ׳Ļظ:

:ǰĳĳ,ʲôҩ,Ͼͺ,ҩ,
鰡!ҵھҲһĲ,Ҳ,˵ҽ?

͵ʵ͵ķ

ھķٷ:

:Ӽ˵,ִҽѧϸ,ʦ,֮
ҲԾٳԼκõĲ

Ժ,˵ҩ,㲻ҩܺ.
ھӳҲ,ҲǺһ״!ӿ,ڶ
!

Ҫ֤ҩЧĻ,ֻһַ,Ǿǽﵽһ
ģٴ,ϸල,аοĶԱ½,
Ҫ,οʹñ˫ä״̬ʹ,ҽ֪,߲֪
.

󾭹ͳ,ʹͳѧó,ųżȻ,ܵó
ҩǲЧ!

һ˵.,ͨ,óҩȷЧ.ôҲ
ƷӵĹ۵.ǡǡ֤һ!

Ϊʲô?ٻصӵĹ۵㱾!ýĹ,
Զﴫ!ܶΪķӵĹ۵,ǷӱĹ۵!

ôӵĹ۵ʲô;ҽ,ҩ!

Ҳ˵ӵĹ۵Ƿϳҽϵ,ʲôľˮ,ʲô
֮ѧ!

û˵:ҩȫûЧ!Ĺ۵ҩеЧ,еûЧ,
ҪִĿѧ,ķȷǷ񱣴!

νķҽҩ!

еѲ,ҽʲô?򵥵һ.
һڵһҽҩһҽ鼮

ȫ:˼ҽ

---------Ȼʱ

:,,1958.ҽѧʿ,,ְֹڹҽѧԺҽѧ
Ժ

Ȿ,ϾͲõ,Լ˵α.

ҽȱʵô͵,˵ҽʵһ֤ʵ,ǲҪ
Ķ,Լ־ȥ֤һʵ.

Ҿ,ʵ,ʵ֤,ôг?ʹ
õģʵҲǽʵʵϵİ.

ڶ,,ΪʲôڵĿѧ鲻ľͼ,Ϊʲôҽľ,
˵ƵھЩ˵ǧľϳֵԭ.

˵ʷϳһ,˾гûеһ,Ǿ
Լ־ĿС

:Ļ,ҽӲһֿѧ,Ϊѧʵţ
,Ҳ.

ֻһܿҶܿĶĻ.ôӦڽ,
ʥ,ܿ͸һ!

ڶ,ߵ:

ϻʱͲȽ,ʱͲ!

Ҫʲôϻ,ҽϻҽûжӦĸ,Ϊ̫,
ϸȾ,Ҳϻ,ȱάҲϻ

Ҫش,Ҿʹûȹ,ҿǻʱҾͳ21ά
ͺ.

ҵ.

˵ʲô?,ⲻйеİ,ȫ綼еİ,ѵ
Ϊҳ˵ҽĹ.

ڿѧ֤⺬ʵĵ!ṩ,ζ,۸
,ϲ!

ҽʲôϵ!~

ҽйʲô,Ҳû,û,ƾʲô˵Ҿҽ
?

,ҽֲ,,ƽʱһֿﶼҩ,,
ȫ綼ҽ?

.ҽǷڴͳĻ?

ǲֻпѧαѧֶ?

Ļѧ?

һֹ۵,ΪϵĶǿѧαѧ,,
Ů̸,еĶŮ˵:Ұ,һһ.,ǲǿѧ?

Ȼ!۾ͱαѧ?ԭ,ǵ,̸
һֱαѧ!

찡,˭̸!

ҽѵ͵ڴͳĻ?

˵ҽһĻһֿѧ?

ѧҪȫطеͨ,ţٵľѧ,й,
,ձҲ,ҽ,ֻйһƬ?˵ǿѧ?

˾˵ڷԴͳĻ,ôҽ͵ڴͳĻ?ҽֻ
ͳѧһСֶ.ҽ,ǻǵİ,˵ѧ,
ʷ.

,Ǳ˹ҽһʶ

ӭ!

вͬĹ۵,ӭȺ.עҽҽ

QQȺ33747046

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

ߡΪʲôôǣ

ߣ̸̲

    Ͽˡߡϵһƪ£0623ϣſξͱ
סҪЦˡ

·ߵҰҪ



1998йһ֧ŮӳԴѧǴظԭ֮һɷõ
˽⽭ԴʶԴĹУѧҲɵ£ۡ
ΪоԴĶֲ״һλѧɽСһƤо
зλѧû뵽ǣٵƬɽȥʱԭ
̵һɽͺɽһɫҲûˡһƤӰһɽ
λѧҺ˵Щʱź
ظԭ̬ڴıȦṹڶ໥ԼģҲ
ǳеġԭһǳˮƽȶ״̬
ĸˮƽ̬ϵͳôḻԣԴ̬ϵͳı
رУһƤһɽ


ظԭ̬ģʮǰ￪ɽƻֲȥһ
ûгϲݡǴҶ֪ġǲ֪ǣظԭһС
ƤȥоһɽӴ˾ͱˣ

ߡѾûпˣǰϲô߰ҷ
һǵĶˣٿǶԼ̵һˣ

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

ʮʿǶ˶ˣʮʿǴ

ߣ     http://blog.sina.com.cn/u/1217515491

20061218գʮʿڷĳ顶߳Ļʶ ͦй
ĻԡּڡͦйĻԡҲͷ¶βҪ衰
زšԲʮλˡþеΡΪ޳ܡ޳ܻҪ
֪ĵǡ꼺աһشڡ
ҵĻ㣬ȷӦǡաעһԴˣ
ȫ

ԭּͳ֧֡ʮʿȤ
ǣЩҪͦйĻԡˣȴ֡йĻԡ
طʣһߴ׵йˡʶûСͦ
йĻԡһȴʮͬҡʶҡͦһͨ
ȫ˷һӲԴġ顱ⲻЦѪ 

ԡʮʿ£дƪ̱ܿڶԣ
ΪйĻȷʵСԡǣйĻڵġԡ
ĻǴͳĻˣʮʿ͡ҡΪġĻ
ԡӦòȡʷ͡ʽġ塱ʮʿƪƪ
һߵؾɸĳζӺܶ΢СĲ̸̸֣
ΪʲôйĻġԡѾı䡣

ȣʮʿдõԷʽǾĻ˶ʱڷͳġ
ѧ˹ԷʽˣʮʿҪͦйĻԡ
ô͸ü׹ģҲҪдֻǲܶԡʮʿ
ͶءķڷȻǧƾõĻɡ


ڶʿdoctor,дDrһĸй
ҲСʿʣƩ硰ƣʿ¿ֽδ¿
֡ϼѵѧġʿָǹŴھѧְ
١仰˵ʿڹŴָѧҲһְֹǣ
ġʿߡʿ󡱣רʡСʿָѧ
λʿָȡòʿѧλȡÿо顢߿Ϊ
ĿġһʱĿлĽѧƶȡڣ˵ǡ
ʿﻹ뵽ǵٵ𣿲ܡȻǣʮ
ڴѧĻרʡʿdoctor
ĻͦйĻԡⲻ˿Цˣʮ
ʿ´ҪͦĻȰԼݸĳɡšߡ֡

ĻҲһ˵ʡνĻڼ书
ơʫ֮ˣΪҲĻģȻ
˵Է䲢á̫ʮ˼衷 仰˵Ļ
йŴһĽͣǡ书ĶӦʡȻ˵
ġĻcivilizationָ뾫Ƹܺ͡
ȫҲŴӰӡ

ɼĻ棬ܶ΢ı仯ͷǲ䣬йͱ
ĻԡˣĵҡҲͲ֪ʲôʱйˣѾ
ˡڣǳڲݿһЩŶ֮⣬ǵУ
ǵΧЩܹġͦйĻԡأԣ
˵йĻԡ͸ıˣȫ˵
Ϻѽܣɷ羰ȴʵ顣

ھϵ֮£Ҳţʲôĸߵ󲻻


20061226賿

ע1йŴġɵ֧귨Ļܷˡó20061218
ǡաҪ1218Ѿˡѩ127գ
ݶʮĽӡѩʼɼ½˸¡ʮʿ
ĴڣáͦйĻԡġɵ֧귨
ʱ򣬾ȻϵʮĽ̫ͦˣ̫˿Ц
ˡңйʷϣá꼺աֵı
ڵģõҪż귨Ʃĩ꣬ȵȡ
ʮʿֹ췽ģҪʦˮ֮ģڣ
ǿɰġʮʿڸˡǣ֮治Уѧ
ɣʿʦһɫ

ڡɵ֧귨ҽһƪۼðͦ
йĻԡ

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

޴

yjyylzbg

Ҫڼѧ˴󲻽⣬й˵ֻϵ
ڹϵһԼأֻȥ߸й
ͳĻˣΪνڡһȷѧһģ
ѧϵͳ12ڣ23ڣ13Ƿڣ˵ˡο
12֮仹Ա޶֮˵ִӺ̸һ
 һһأһأһأɼ뿪
˾̸ڷڵͻ໥һֻʯ
ͷԱҲ˰ɣη໥أӺ
ԾͷʯҲΪ໥áɣйᲴڣ
ڣϵϵĸᷢ໥ãغ
˶ֱ֪ϡʲô˼˵ֱڶ໥
á֪ʲô˼׫һЩ˭Ҳˣ޴
ˮ

    ѧϵĵ޴Сʼʹ޶ĵۼӴСΪ㣬
ۻȴ˸򣬲֪ĵǸʲô㣿Īǡʮ㡱

    νڼغҲĪĸѵھӾס

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

Ʒɺ裬ҮգαѧʥӸ

ܷɳ

ٽĩˣһֵҲϢģ˶ͼϲ
ĽգǰǲȤٽսĸ߳ˡ
סĵط̫ƫԶ˿ûиܵʥգһûʲô£Ҳ
ǿһӰƬһ˿ȴҲЩӸСܶЩ
Ŀû·׽һ֣һȤζ

һ¡Ʒɺ.жǿͷ˵Ʒɺμһҽ
ѧ飬ڻͨչʾѨۺʵǰչҽ
˵ķסѨʹҽϥӦܷҸȫ
ҽҲҽǲܡסѨ޷֤ƾ󣬾
Ѩ˵ڣ÷Ͳ
ǧȻѧ˵߼˻ĵһѧѵ
šνѨһȽе񾭴أһЩδ
ǵ١ȻҽҪ㾭оԵúܻޱҪ
޳ѨλĸֻҪԼΪѧǿΪһ
߼ĴڣΪһ;ʵǱҪ
̫ȭʱȻеȫʼڽһ֡
ﵽһľϵƽе˿ܾҪá硱
򵼣йء˵ֱõͨ޵
޲ɣʲͬȡѣ

תһƪۡԼ£̴˵ķ
ǳ۵ġѧIIϿʱ񸸽̴Լ߳ȥ͵
ˡ̲ס˵̫ϧ˰ɡŭѵΪҮյ̴
ˣǵǰɡ룬ҪҮգҮվͲᱻ
Үûûʮּܴιʧҵ֪𣿡һֵĵӰ
ӡ֤ȻоֵֹģȴҲʵѧУ̻״ձܵ
ýѧм䣬Ľ̻ʿѾΪЦ׾һ
ʥ͸ñΪʷо˵ʵҹȽ׾ѧͷ
ǺѵģС顶׾ֱ⡷ǰ˵ֻһŴ
ռ顱оϹʱڵģȴǼѵõʷϡ
ʶжã

α֮Ȼδ㿴³˵Ĺ۵㣬αѧ֮˵
пѧһʵǣѧ۵Ľݱ˫
ָαѧĶ֪ʿ벻˭ˣһЩ֮ĳ
ͻҲαѧָ˽ȥȻʹΪαǱҪǾʹˡ
ˡǿ͹۴ڵģǱʶѧ֮бġα
ѧڼʹżˣġͳѧǶȿѿ
ѧֲ̬ܹȷʶ95%ѧ㹻ˣʣ
5%ˣԿʱļֲѧվ˵ġ֮
Ҫסߵ죬ڰΪʵʵ100%ȻǲԸ룬
Ҳ룬Ϊ翵5%ҪŽֳִĲӬҷ
ԼǲӬģ͸̹ȻѧɡѧɿѧǳӦ
ġѧ֮ѧαѧͱ˴Ļĵ


(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

ѧоռì

Ϳ

ˣȫ˼ʱѧ⣬ĸҵ
˿۵ѧʽǴˡΪ̸ѧܵ
ҪĸţоѧʵͬʱҪչ˵ռǾֻһ
ռѧʶáռķʽоѧʣѣ

ȣ㲻̸ѧ˸Ȥ⡣һ̸۴ըۣ
ѧҾͶ㣬У㷢߼㲻Ϸ޸İ˹̹ۺ
ռһεĴըۡҵĿѧվ;յ
ԼˣֻҪһˡм߻רŽҵƫ
վӣ㲻ʤ䷳ƸȤûд£Ҫ
ƶԻͼǿգûûˡһѡ

Σ㻹۴ڸȤ⡣ҽ˵ҽ֮⣬
һѧģǿѧĻѧı˼ҲҪ˼
ΪԼԹҩҽзȨˣϻҽ
вΪǧָĭ֮Сд
£˵ҩ˵˵һ˵⣬˵кܶ˾
˺ܶӣмأȻ۵ķҲУγ֤ǿ֧
ǵĹ۵㣬˵ҶĵزҪϣ˼ռһ£Ǽ
ֱϹӵư׷˶ѡ

ٴΣҪмå磬ʵåϵ
Ȼٲˡ˵ĻԲ⣬ͷ˵ȥˣSBSBSB
֮ˡ

ضҪͻƣڱںһ
˵ӲҪκι˵Ҹ桱ͻΪ¼ҹˡ

ӺѵȫȻ˵ĳ̶ȣ̫١зƣ
ſںǲСҪԵıʵҾͻ˺ܶҸ棬˵
Ϊʲôĸо£ҸѾҵĹ
۵Σĳ̶ˡ

Ϊʲô۷ҽαѧͻѣԾġ
ƽ̨ѧ־ضȺĵطһ磬ɫ
˵ӴӴˣʲôСֻϹŮҷ˿ǵżǸ
ûˣһֻС硱ˡ

Ҫҽαѧ⣬͹˲ˡԼ·
ñȥ

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

ѧͺõļݵȴ



A.

κͱ˾תʳƷۡڷתʳƷĹ۵У
һģڵĳּûоƾ𲻰Ѿڳּ
ϣתٵʮ겻𣿡

Ҿֹ۵ʮֿЦΪѧͺõļǲݵȴġ

ҪѧͺõļݵȴɣǼֱ̫ˡӸ˵ĽǶȽһ
ѧҺͼұǿҵȤͺϣΪ֪ʶʱô
ԸԼ̽ǿдϣñһҪĩһڴѾõıͻȻ
֪òȥӰ࣬ܲܣֺñһɽ߲ɽʧȥ˫
ţӴ˸Ȱ̽ҵܲźɵ뵽ʱｨ鷥
ɣ̾²⣬ʮӰ˾šÿÿΪ֮ڵ
ѧҺͼٰװί

ӹҵĽǶȽֻҪϻһ죬֮ͻ
һ죬ƼĹңȻҪڹʾռƣԶڿƼв
ĹңΨŬϣĳһĳϣԼӦлԸ
档ս纽ƼķչĹףκοƼʷѧҶϵģ
ȻеζҺĳЩߣڱķ˭
һתʳƷ¡棬ȴֱߣ߼ϵĻ
ңܲ˳䣡

ȫĽǶȽһֱãûпƼĽҲǽĳһ
ΣԵȫ̫ˣЩս
ڽ̳ͻȡҲȥ˵νȻĳͷѾˡ
նЧӦŵꡢȾĮѾ
ӦˣͨΣеģҲԴΣʱ
ֵĳˮҳ룬ʯ͸֮ǰǻչܳȡ֮
ڴԴ罫һ۵ֹߣҼţ಻
ôȡһŵʱÿһΣһԻΪġʱ
ѧҺͼѲ˲

Щ֡ȴۡˣЩ
 
B.

Щáᡱ̸̸ҵ

־һֲѧҡ֪й3άֲڰ
ǣΪԴνḻǶֲоȴû
ǰСѾȫġйֲ־Ϲģֲ־ҹֲ
ѧĽǾһλѧ͸¶ѧڱ༭ǹҵֲɫͼʱ
˶汾ġձֲ־Сֲ־ûСйֲ
־ǰԽѧڱԽҹ߾ĵط·һֲֵ֮
мѱ걾͸ǣǷ͸ձͶ˹ΪһйѧߣȻ
ܲԴź

ҷ֣ҹֲоҪԭ֮һǻɽͷΪϰߡ
ضһЩõϣܹȫЧϣΪãһ
빦شٽֲѧоеĵλֿǣǲԸ⹫Լ
ͷϡȻܶ£ǵĹǶ⣬Ϊϰѧ
㣬Ҳǲܷϵʵ

׼һĿԭĳطλԺܿɣΪһ
޿ȨΪõطλϣֲãֻȫԼ
װ˺ܶظͶ޿κΡĵģ˵
ҪĿⲻ˷Ϊʲôȵȣ

ǰоΪ˻ڷԣΪ˴ӵλ׷ȻȢӣ
ȻԡȵȡбǨͱˣչ˱˵κģҵ
ȻҲԡȵȡΪһȰҵˣΪԼľ
ҲΪйֲѧҵһﵽȽˮƽΪ˶ԴڵҪ
ʵڲԸ⡰ȵȡȻ֪ͻˣͻԼķչ
ϰ

ɹԸʡ
 
2006.12.26
ġѧū־http://blog.sina.com.cn/u/1216002517

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

Sam Harrisһ֮šи

ϼһο

S˵"ҼҺԺһŵôʯ"

ֵͷҪһ£"Ϊʲô㿴ʯˣ"

"ûСȷĴڡ"

"Ϊʲô"Խ

"ҵĸĸǰסǾҼҺԺһŵô
ʯҵ游ĸ游ĸҲ---ҲҼҺԺһŵ
ôʯôҵ塣"

"ԹҺԺһŵôʯл
"

"㻹ǲףǵʽЧ,ΪʲôҪȥ
أ"

"ôЧ"

"㿴ǵļͥΪǼҶźԺһ
ôʯǵбͷЩżʯİ飬
ҴûСУҼһԼҺԺ˵ô
ʯһǾ;һԼҵʯ޸裬˸ŮСһ
ڣⶼżʯĺô"

"£"

"Ȼ! ֻȫΧڳ˶ԼҺԺ
˵ôʯҵļͥ
˸㷺˼硣Ҳһ㿴Щ׻Ѿ
;ˣԴҺԺ˵ôʯҲ͵
-----ԼҾôһ޼֮ΪʲôҪȥΥ?
У˱ǸƹԴҺԺ˵ôʯ
˾, õȫżʯ˵֧֣Ϊ˹!
ѵûʶԼҺԺһŵôʯĺô
"

Ŷԭˡ

(XYS20061227)

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)

һΪ˰޷˿վĹ˽˿վĶ̬ؿ
˿ʼбxys@yahoogroups.com

ʼбÿ췢һ˿վ¸µϣÿµ׷һÿ
Ŀ¼ʼбĶμ롰˿֮ѡ
ʼбxys_friends@yahoogroups.com

ù䶩ġù䣬ܿ޷յ
Ƽ䣺yahoo.com, hotmail.com, gmail.com

ġ˿ʼбĵ䷢һհż

xys-subscribe@yahoogroups.com 

塢ͣ˿ʼбͣ䷢һհż

xys-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com 

Ͷxinyusi@yahoo.comôıļͶ塣

˿(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)